Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

Department of Plant Sciences

UC Davis

Extraction abilities of methods used for estimating of different phosphorus fractions

Abstract

Soil samples (from Czech and German long term field experiments) were used for estimating soil phosphorus (P) fractions. More then 100 topsoil (0-30 cm) samples from different fertilizing treatments were taken. These were analysed for P in soil solution (PCaCl2), exchangeable sorbed P (Pex) and bioavailable P. The methods used were 0,01M CaCl2 extracts, anion exchange (AE) membranes, Doppel-Lactat (PDL) and Mehlich 3 (PM3). Other fractions analysed were total inorganic (Pin), total (PM-tot) and organic (Porg) P estimated with Marks (1977) fractionation, P sorbed on Fe and Al (PFeAl) and residual P (Par). Comparison of medians appeared to be better for evaluating extraction abilities. Phosphorus fractions increased in the following order: [Par =100%]; PCaCl2 (0.1%) < Pex (10%) < PDL (12%) < PM3 (17%) < Pin (25%) < Porg (38%) < PM-tot (60%) < PFeAl (62%). Low amounts of Pin, Porg and PM-tot did not verified the applicability of Marks fractionation for the set of studied soils. Close correlations at α<0.001 were found for all methods for estimating the fractions of bioavailable phosphates (PCaCl2, Pex, PDL a PM3). Statistically significant relations were observed between Pin with Par, PM-tot and PFeAl.

Main Content
For improved accessibility of PDF content, download the file to your device.
Current View