Homeopathic remedies made primarily from eggshells, and therefore calcium, can be marketed for treatment of back pain and vaginal discharge. We present a case of a 23-year-old otherwise healthy woman who presented with acute liver failure (ALF) ultimately requiring liver transplantation as a result of taking increased doses of a homeopathic product with the primary ingredient of eggshells. Although relatively uncommon compared with medications such as acetaminophen, herbal supplements have been reported to cause drug-induced liver injury (DILI), thought to be primarily due to contaminants. This is the first known report of DILI resulting from a homeopathic product with the primary ingredient of eggshells, and it demonstrates the importance of early ALF recognition and treatment, as well as the importance of practicing caution when using homeopathic supplements.