This research aimed to evaluate, develop, and refine chemical and cultural controls for branched broomrape in processing tomato, a quarantine pest in California. Branched broomrape is an obligate parasite that can attach to the roots of a wide range of plants, particularly tomato and other agricultural crops. Interest in strategies for management of branched broomrape in processing tomatoes has been growing in California and Chile where tomatoes are major cash crops. Chapter 1 aimed to evaluate and develop herbicide programs based on programs developed in Israel for Egyptian broomrape control in tomato. Crop safety and efficacy studies evaluating preplant incorporated (PPI) sulfosulfuron paired with chemigated imazamox as well as limited treatments including chemigated rimsulfuron were conducted in California and Chile. Chemigated imazamox alone and paired with PPI sulfosulfuron generally reduced broomrape emergence; however, chemigated imazamox resulted in unacceptable crop injury in most trials at rates higher than 9.6 g ai/ha. Chemigated rimsulfuron alone or paired with PPI sulfosulfuron reduced broomrape emergence and did not injure tomatoes. Over several field trials, chemigated imazamox did not have adequate safety in tomato and will not be pursued further
In the 2021 and 2022 studies evaluating the crop safety and efficacy of chemigated imazamox, there were differences in crop injury between field sites in California: imazamox-treated tomatoes in the Davis site only experienced minor early season injury while tomatoes at the Woodland site were severely injured or killed. Chapter 2 aimed to investigate the cause of this discrepancy in injury. A study was conducted to investigate imazamox sorption in four California soils to determine if differences in herbicide adsorption played a role in variable crop injury observed in the California field trials. To determine the sorption capacity of imazamox of each soil, a batch equilibrium study was conducted. There were significant differences in sorbed imazamox: the clay soil had the highest adsorption, followed by the sandy loam soil, while the loam soils from the Davis and Woodland trial sites had the lowest adsorption and were not significantly different from one another. The results from this study illustrate only minor differences in imazamox adsorption among the soils tested which suggests that soil type was likely not a major factor contributing to the discrepancy in imazamox injury in the earlier field trials.
Chapter 3 aimed to further develop and refine chemigated rimsulfuron treatments. Following the lack of crop safety of chemigated imazamox and positive results of chemigated rimsulfuron in field studies in 2022, field research was conducted in 2023 and 2024 to evaluate various application timings of chemigated rimsulfuron alone, PPI sulfosulfuron paired with chemigated rimsulfuron, as well as foliar maleic hydrazide alone and in combination with PPI sulfosulfuron and chemigated rimsulfuron. In 2023, all treatments with a total of 70 g ai/ha rimsulfuron alone or paired with PPI sulfosulfuron reduced broomrape emergence 77-92% compared to the nontreated control (P<0.0001). In 2024, all rimsulfuron treatments reduced broomrape emergence 68-86% compared to the nontreated control (P<0.0001). In both years, five applications of foliar maleic hydrazide reduced broomrape emergence through at least midseason; however, in 2024 a late flush of broomrape was observed in late summer in these treatments. The 2024 combination treatment of PPI sulfosulfuron, chemigated rimsulfuron, and foliar maleic hydrazide was the best treatment overall, reducing broomrape emergence 96% versus the nontreated control (P<0.0001). Under a recently approved 24c label, growers can currently use three applications of rimsulfuron applied via chemigation to suppress broomrape in known infested fields or to reduce the risk of broomrape in fields of concern for this quarantine pest. Promising results from sulfosulfuron and maleic hydrazide suggest that the registration of additional herbicides could help develop even more robust branched broomrape management programs.
Chapter 4 aimed to evaluate integrated cultural control practices for branched broomrape management. Although there are now approved herbicides for in-season management, the development of integrated pest management strategies is needed to reduce the current infestation and mitigate the spread of this highly-regulated parasitic weed. Herbicide efficacy research was conducted in 2020 and 2021 in a field known to be highly infested with branched broomrape; however, during the 2021 experiment no broomrape emerged in any plots. Because tomato cultivar and planting dates differed between the two years, several experiments were conducted to evaluate the impact of cultivar and transplant date on broomrape parasitism in processing tomato. A greenhouse study to evaluate variation in broomrape resistance across 20 cultivars, including the cultivar planted in the 2021 trial (‘SVTM 9024’) and 19 other top commercial cultivars was conducted in 2022 and repeated in 2023 and 2024. Resistance was evaluated based on ability to host broomrape as well as temporal differences in broomrape emergence. In field studies, variation in resistance was also evaluated, with several commercial processing tomato varieties and grafted combinations evaluated during 2022, 2023, and 2024. Planting date studies were also conducted in 2022 and 2024 to evaluate the effects of delayed tomato transplanting on broomrape emergence. Results from the 2022 greenhouse screening indicated that all cultivars, including ‘SVTM 9024’, were susceptible to broomrape parasitism, but that there could be variation in temporal emergence. The 2023 greenhouse studies confirmed this, with significant variation in the timing of broomrape emergence between ‘SVTM 9025’ and ‘H9553’ (P=0.05). The 2024 greenhouse study conducted in mid-summer had no broomrape emergence in any of the cultivars, likely due to hot conditions in the greenhouse leading to secondary dormancy of the preconditioned seed. Field cultivar studies conducted in 2023 and 2024 showed no significant differences in broomrape emergence among conventional or grafted cultivar combinations (P = 0.23, 0.74); results for the non-grafted cultivars were consistent with greenhouse studies. Broomrape was significantly reduced by later planting dates in the 2024 trial (P = <0.001), with no emergence at the latest planting date (June 10, 2024); 2022 planting date study was consistent with these results, with a 52% reduction on emergence at the later date, although differences were not significant (P = 0.21). Taken together, these experiments suggest that there is some variation in resistance among the tested commercial cultivars and delayed transplanting seems to reduce broomrape emergence and future research will seek to confirm this.