The relationship between sentence production and comprehension is at the forefront of psycholinguistic research (e.g.Meyer et al., 2016). Psycholinguists are increasingly interested in cross-linguistic perspectives (e.g. Norcliffe et al., 2015).We report studies of the production and comprehension of variable number agreement in Yucatec Maya, an indigenouslanguage of Mexico. We examined the effects of numerosity through a picture description task involving sets of one,two and seven humans or animals depicting an intransitive action. In production more numerous sets led to higher rates ofplural production. In a timed acceptability decision task, number agreement rather than numerosity significantly facilitatedcomprehension. An interaction revealed that plural marking on the noun facilitated the comprehension of singleton versusnon-singleton sets. In contrast, plural marking on the verb facilitated comprehension of large versus small non-singletonsets. These results suggest divergent effects of numerosity in the nominal and verbal domains.