To date, 12 protein lysine methyltransferases that modify translational elongation factors and ribosomal proteins (Efm1-7 and Rkm 1-5) have been identified in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Of these 12, five (Efm1 and Efm4-7) appear to be specific to elongation factor 1A (EF1A), the protein responsible for bringing aminoacyl-tRNAs to the ribosome. In S. cerevisiae, the functional implications of lysine methylation in translation are mostly unknown. In this work, we assessed the physiological impact of disrupting EF1A methylation in a strain where four of the most conserved methylated lysine sites are mutated to arginine residues and in strains lacking either four or five of the Efm lysine methyltransferases specific to EF1A. We found that loss of EF1A methylation was not lethal but resulted in reduced growth rates, particularly under caffeine and rapamycin stress conditions, suggesting EF1A interacts with the TORC1 pathway, as well as altered sensitivities to ribosomal inhibitors. We also detected reduced cellular levels of the EF1A protein, which surprisingly was not reflected in its stability in vivo. We present evidence that these Efm methyltransferases appear to be largely devoted to the modification of EF1A, finding no evidence of the methylation of other substrates in the yeast cell. This work starts to illuminate why one protein can need five different methyltransferases for its functions and highlights the resilience of yeast to alterations in their posttranslational modifications.