Proton computed tomography (pCT) has been proposed as an alternative to x-ray computed tomography (CT) for acquiring relative to water stopping power (RSP) maps used for proton treatment planning dose calculations. In parallel, it has been shown that dual energy x-ray CT (DECT) improves RSP accuracy when compared to conventional single energy x-ray CT. This study aimed at directly comparing the RSP accuracy of both modalities using phantoms scanned at an advanced prototype pCT scanner and a state-of-the-art DECT scanner. Two phantoms containing 13 tissue-mimicking inserts of known RSP were scanned at the pCT phase II prototype and a latest generation dual-source DECT scanner (Siemens SOMATOM Definition FORCE). RSP accuracy was compared by mean absolute percent error (MAPE) over all inserts. A highly realistic Monte Carlo (MC) simulation was used to gain insight on pCT image artifacts which degraded MAPE. MAPE was 0.55% for pCT and 0.67% for DECT. The realistic MC simulation agreed well with pCT measurements ([Formula: see text]). Both simulation and experimental results showed ring artifacts in pCT images which degraded the MAPE compared to an ideal pCT simulation ([Formula: see text]). Using the realistic simulation, we could identify sources of artifacts, which are attributed to the interfaces in the five-stage plastic scintillator energy detector and calibration curve interpolation regions. Secondary artifacts stemming from the proton tracker geometry were also identified. The pCT prototype scanner outperformed a state-of-the-art DECT scanner in terms of RSP accuracy (MAPE) for plastic tissue mimicking inserts. Since artifacts tended to concentrate in the inserts, their mitigation may lead to further improvements in the reported pCT accuracy.

Purpose

This experimental study is aimed at demonstrating, using a simple cylindrical water phantom, the feasibility of fluence-modulated proton computed tomography (FMpCT) by pencil beam scanning (PBS) proton computed tomography (pCT).

Methods

The phase II pCT prototype of the Loma Linda U. and U. C. Santa Cruz was operated using the PBS beam line of the Northwestern Medicine Chicago Proton Center. A 20 × 10 grid of 1.37 cm full width half maximum pencil beams (PB) equally spaced by 1 cm was used to acquire 45 projections in step and shoot mode. The PB pattern's fluence was modified to allow FMpCT scans with fluence modulation factors (FMF) of 50% and 20%. A central FMpCT region of interest (FMpCT-ROI) was used to define a high image quality region. Reconstructed images were evaluated in terms of relative stopping power (RSP) accuracy and noise using annular ROIs. The FMpCT dose savings were estimated by Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of the pCT acquisitions using beam phase space distributions. PBS pCT results with homogeneous fluence were additionally compared to broad beam results in terms of RSP accuracy and noise.

Results

PBS pCT scans with acceptable pileup were possible, and images were comparable to previously acquired broad beam pCT images in terms of both noise and accuracy. In the FMpCT-ROI, the noise and accuracy from full fluence (FF) scans were preserved. Dose savings of up to 60% were achieved at the object's edge when using FMF of 20%.

Conclusion

In this study, we have demonstrated that PBS pCT scans can achieve equivalent accuracy as those obtained from broad beams. The feasibility of FMpCT scans was demonstrated; image accuracy and noise were successfully preserved in the central FMpCT-ROI chosen for this study, and dose reduction of up to 60% at the object's edge was realized.