The Santa Barbara Basin is an extraordinary archive of environmental and ecological change, where varved sediments preserve microfossils that provide an annual to decadal record of the dynamics of surrounding ecosystems. Of the microfossils preserved in these sediments, benthic foraminifera are the most abundant seafloor-dwelling organisms. While they have been extensively utilized for geochemical and paleoceanographic work, studies of their morphology are lacking. Here we use a high-throughput imaging method (AutoMorph) designed to extract 2D data from photographic images of fossils to produce a large image and 2D shape dataset of recent benthic foraminifera from two core records sampled from the center of the Santa Barbara Basin that span an ~800-year-long interval during the Common Era (1249-2008 CE). Information on more than 36,000 objects is included, of which more than 22,000 are complete or partially-damaged benthic foraminifera. The dataset also includes other biogenic microfossils including ostracods, pteropods, diatoms, radiolarians, fish teeth, and shark dermal denticles. We describe our sample preparation, imaging, and identification techniques, and outline potential data uses.