We measure the impact of two main signals of tertiary-level human capital accumulation, college quality and certification, on hiring in India. Using a correspondence experiment, we send 16,944 resumes to 1,412 job postings for recent engineering graduates at small and medium firms. We do not find evidence that either of the two signals that we consider have effects on callbacks separately. Specifically, the impact of having graduated from a mid-tier college ranked in the top 300 relative to an unranked college outside of the top 1000 is close to zero and precisely estimated, despite significant government investment in ranking colleges in India. There is also a precisely estimated null effect of scoring in the highest as opposed to the lowest quartile of a post-tertiary certification test that has been taken by millions of graduating students. Resumes with female names modestly benefit in this first stage of the hiring process.