Subepidermal calcified nodules are an uncommon subtype of idiopathic calcinosis cutis. Morphologically, this entity typically present as a single, well-circumscribed, white-yellow nodule. Based on clinical appearance alone, subepidermal calcified nodules are frequently misdiagnosed and often requires histological confirmation. We describe two cases of subepidermal calcified nodules presenting atypically as cutaneous horns. Subepidermal calcified nodules presenting as a cutaneous horn has rarely been reported; on review, there are fewer than 10 such cases have been described within the past 30 years. The cases described here illustrate the clinical variety and should increase awareness of subepidermal calcified nodules presented.