Despite its long history and reliability, contrast angiography has several inherent limitations. Because it is a two-dimensional projection image of the lumen contour, the wall thickness cannot be measured and the plaque itself is not visualized. This results in an underestimation of the amount of atherosclerotic disease by angiography. An assessment of atherosclerosis could be improved by an imaging modality: (1) that has an inherent larger magnification than angiography and (2) that directly visualizes the plaque. Intravascular ultrasound fulfils these criteria. This presentation will provide evidence that intravascular ultrasound may prove complimentary or even superior to angiography as an imaging modality. Intravascular ultrasound demonstrates excellent representations of lumen and plaque morphology of in vitro specimens compared with histology. There is very close intraobserver and interobserver variability of measurements made from intravascular ultrasound images. Phantom studies of stenoses in a tube model demonstrate that angiography can misrepresent the severity of stenosis when the lumen contour is irregular and not a typical ellipse, whereas intravascular ultrasound reproduces the cross-sectional morphology more accurately since it images the artery from within. In vitro studies of the atherosclerotic plaque tissue characteristics compare closely with the echo representation of fibrosis, calcification, and lipid material. In addition, in vitro studies of balloon angioplasty demonstrate that intravascular ultrasound accurately represents the changes in the structure of artery segments following balloon dilatation.

Background

Histological examination of the effects of balloon angioplasty have been described from in vitro experiments and a limited number of pathologic specimens. Intravascular ultrasound imaging permits real time cross-sectional observation of the effect of balloon dilation on the atherosclerotic plaque in vivo.

Methods and results

The morphological effects of coronary angioplasty were visualized at 66 lesions in 47 patients immediately after balloon dilatation with an intravascular ultrasound imaging catheter. Cross-sectional images were obtained at 30 frames per second as the catheter passed along the length of the artery. Quantitative and qualitative assessments of the dilated atherosclerotic plaque were made from the angiograms and the ultrasound images. Six morphological patterns after angioplasty were appreciated by ultrasound imaging. Type A consists of a linear, partial tear of the plaque from the lumen toward the media (seven lesions); Type B is defined by a split in the plaque that extends to the media (12 lesions); Type C demonstrates a dissection behind the plaque that subtends an arc of up to 180 degrees around the circumference (18 lesions); Type D was a more extensive dissection that encompasses an arc of more than 180 degrees (four lesions); and Type E may be present in either concentric (Type E1, 14 lesions) or eccentric (Type E2, 11 lesions) plaque and is defined as an ultrasound study without any evidence of a fracture or a dissection in the plaque. There was a large amount of residual atheroma in each type of morphology (7.8 +/- 2.9 mm2, 61.6 +/- 15.4% of cross-sectional area); there was no difference, however, in lumen or atheroma cross-sectional area among these six patterns. There was a good correlation between ultrasound and angiography for the recognition of a dissection. Calcification was seen in only 14% of lesions on angiography, whereas most lesions (83%) revealed calcification on ultrasound imaging. As determined by intravascular ultrasound, calcified plaque was more likely to fracture in response to balloon dilatation than noncalcified plaque (p less than 0.01). Thirteen of 66 lesions (20%) developed clinical and angiographic restenosis. Restenosis was more likely to occur when the original dilatation left a concentric plaque without a fracture or dissection (Type E1, 50% incidence) compared with a mean restenosis rate of 12% in the remaining morphological patterns (p = 0.053).

Conclusions

Intravascular ultrasound provides a more complete quantitative and qualitative description of plaque geometry and composition than angiography after balloon angioplasty. In addition, intravascular ultrasound identified a subset of atherosclerotic plaque that has a higher incidence of restenosis. This information could be used prospectively to consider other therapeutic options in this subset. Intravascular ultrasound provides a method to describe the effects of angioplasty that will be useful in comparing future coronary intervention studies.