To identify long-term effects of traumatic brain injury (TBI) on levels of plasma neuron-derived exosome (NDE) protein biomarkers of cognitive impairment (CI), plasmas were obtained from four groups of older veterans, who were matched for age and sex: no TBI or CI (n = 42), no TBI with CI (n = 19), TBI without CI (n = 21), and TBI with CI (n = 26). The TBI was sustained 12 to 74 years before the study in 75%. The NDEs were enriched by sequential precipitation and anti-L1CAM antibody immunoabsorption, and extracted protein biomarkers were quantified by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. Chronic NDE biomarkers known to increase for three to 12 months after TBI, including cellular prion protein (PrPc), synaptogyrin-3, P-T181-tau, P-S396-tau, Aβ42, and interleukin (IL)-6, were elevated significantly in subjects who had TBI and CI compared with controls with TBI but no CI. Chronic NDE biomarker levels in subjects without TBI showed significantly higher levels of PrPc, synaptogyrin-3, P-T181-tau, and Aβ42, but not P-S396-tau and IL-6, in those with CI compared with controls without CI. The acute NDE biomarkers claudin-5, annexin VII, and aquaporin-4 were not increased in either group with CI. The NDE biomarkers P-S396-tau and IL-6, which are increased distinctively with CI after TBI, may prove useful in evaluating CI in older patients. Aβ42 and P-tau species, as well as their respective putative receptors, PrPc and synaptogyrin-3, remain elevated for decades after TBI and may mediate TBI-associated CI and be useful targets for development of drugs.