Compound-specific isotopic analysis of amino acids (CSIA-AA) is increasingly used in ecological and biogeochemical studies tracking the origin and fate of nitrogen (N). Its advantages include the potential for resolving finer-scale trophic dynamics than possible with standard bulk SIA and for reconstructing historical changes in the food webs of consumers from analyses of specimens in preserved sample archives. For the latter, assessing the effects of chemical preservatives on δ15NAA has been inconclusive because the conventional CSIA approach for derivatized AAs by gas chromatography-combustion-isotope ratio mass spectrometry (GC-C-IRMS) has analytical errors (0.4–1.0‰) in the range expected from chemical preservation. Here, we show improved analytical precision (0.15 ± 0.08‰) for 11 underivatized AA standards analyzed by high-pressure liquid chromatography followed by offline elemental analysis-IRMS (HPLC/EA-IRMS). Using this method, we report the first high-precision tests of preservation effects on δ15NAA in Northern Anchovy (Engraulis mordax) kept 1.5-yr in ethanol and up to 27-yr in formaldehyde. We found minimal methodological induced fractionation for eight AAs, and preservation effects on δ15N were similar regardless of duration and preservative used. Although some of the AAs differed significantly from frozen control samples (AA average +1.0 ± 0.8‰), changes in δ15N in the source AA phenylalanine and trophic position estimates were statistically insignificant. Our results are encouraging for resolving fine-scale natural variability using HPLC/EA-IRMS on chemically preserved specimens and for ultimately reconstructing biogeochemical records and trophic dynamics over long time scales.

Although massive biomass fluctuations of coastal-pelagic fishes are an iconic example of the impacts of climate variability on marine ecosystems, the mechanisms governing these dynamics are often elusive. We construct a 45-year record of nitrogen stable isotopes measured in larvae of Northern Anchovy (Engraulis mordax) in the California Current Ecosystem to assess patterns in food chain length. Larval trophic efficiency associated with a shortened food chain increased larval survival and produced boom periods of high adult biomass. In contrast, when larval food chain length increased, and energy transfer efficiency decreased, the population crashed. We propose the Trophic Efficiency in Early Life (TEEL) hypothesis, which states that larval fishes must consume prey that confer sufficient energy for survival, to help explain natural boom-bust dynamics of coastal pelagic fishes. Our findings illustrate a potential for trophic indicators to generally inform larval survival and adult population dynamics of coastal-pelagic fishes.

Abstract: Biomass fluctuations of small coastal-pelagic fishes represent perhaps the most iconic temporal record of the impacts of natural climate variability on marine ecosystems1,2,3. These fishes are key constituents of the marine pelagic food web as primary feeders on plankton, prey to higher trophic level foragers such as birds, marine mammals, piscivore fishes4,5 and valued for human consumption and industry6. Despite over a century of research, the mechanisms governing their population volatility remain elusive7,8. Here, we use a 45-year record of nitrogen stable isotopes measured in larvae of Northern Anchovy (Engraulis mordax) in the California Current to assess patterns in food chain length. Larval trophic efficiency associated with a shortened food chain increased for boom periods of high adult biomass, during which the ratio of large to small larvae decreased by an order of magnitude. In contrast, the ratio increased during periods of low adult biomass, likely reflecting a higher rate of early larval mortality. For the first time, we connect energy transfer efficiency to early larval survival, which in turn regulates the decadal-scale volatility of anchovy biomass, leading to the proposal of the Trophic Efficiency in Early Life (TEEL) hypothesis. Our findings illustrate a potential for trophic indicators to inform on the condition and recruitment to coastal-pelagic fish populations.

2022 marked the third consecutive La Niña and extended the longest consecutive stretch of negative Oceanic Niño Index since 1998-2001. While physical and biological conditions in winter and spring largely adhered to prior La Niña conditions, summer and fall were very different. Similar to past La Niña events, in winter and spring coastal upwelling was either average or above average, temperature average or below average, salinity generally above average. In summer and fall, however, upwelling and temperature were generally average or slightly below average, salinity was close to average and chlorophyll a was close to average. Again, as during prior La Niña events, biomass of northern/southern copepods was above/below average off Oregon in winter, and body size of North Pacific krill in northern California was above average in winter. By contrast, later in the year the abundance of northern krill dropped off Oregon while southern copepods increased and body sizes of North Pacific krill fell in northern California. Off Oregon and Washington abundances of market squid and Pacific pompano (indicators of warm, non-typical La Niña conditions) were high. In the 20th century, Northern anchovy recruitment tended to be high during cold conditions, but despite mostly warm conditions from 2015-2021 anchovy populations boomed and remained high in 2022. Resident seabird reproductive success, which tended in the past to increase during productive La Niña conditions was highly variable throughout the system as common murre and pelagic cormorant, experienced complete reproductive failure at Yaquina Head, Oregon while Brandt’s cormorant reproduction was average. At three sampling locations off central California, however, common murre reproduction was close to or above average while both pelagic and Brandt’s cormorant were above average. California sealion reproduction has been above average each year since 2016, and pup weight was also above average in 2022, likely in response not to La Niña or El Niño but continuous high abundance of anchovy. The highly variable and often unpredictable physical and biological conditions in 2022 highlight a growing recognition of disconnects between basin-scale indices and local conditions in the CCE. “July-December 2022 is the biggest outlier from individual “strong” La Niña (events) ever going back to the 50s.” – Nate Mantua