Benign mesothelial inclusions in pelvic lymph nodes may be mistaken for metastatic disease in the setting of pelvic malignancy. In this case-report a patient with Low-Risk prostate cancer (confirmed by biopsy and genomic testing) underwent radical prostatectomy with pelvic lymph node dissection. The initial pathological diagnosis was organ-confined Gleason 3 + 3 = 6 cancer with metastasis to a pelvic lymph node. Upon review of the pathological specimen and immunohistochemical staining the lymph node tissue concerning for metastatic disease was recharacterized as mesothelial in origin. This case illustrates the importance of second opinions and immunohistochemistry for unexpected or unusual pathological findings.