UC Berkeley

Background

Transgender and nonbinary (TNB) individuals assigned female sex at birth experience discrimination, misgendering, problems with insurance, and denial of services when accessing health care. This study aimed to understand the experiences of TNB young adults in accessing "women's" health care-a form of care that is structurally gendered that few studies have investigated.

Methods

In 2015, we conducted in-depth interviews with 20 TNB young (ages 18-29) adults assigned female sex at birth. We thematically analyzed the data.

Results

Participants described feelings of comfort and trust-and lack thereof-at every step of the health care-seeking process, including scheduling, checking in, waiting, and interactions with clinicians and other staff. Gendered language served as a constant stressor; participants-especially nonbinary participants-noted few opportunities to provide their correct pronouns and names. Participants relayed negative experiences associated with waiting rooms in "women's" health care spaces, where TNB patients are forced to disclose their identity simply through their presence or owing to actions of staff that out them. These concerns deterred some from seeking care, with most expressing discomfort or anxiety that caused them to feel unsafe. Participants described "women's" health care providers making assumptions about their anatomy, reproductive desires, sexual orientation, and sexual practices, as well as inappropriately and harmfully emphasizing their bodies and TNB identities during health care interactions. Clinician competence and humility engendered participants' feelings of safety and undergirded their interest in engaging with "women's" health care.

Conclusions

A lack of patient-centered, TNB-competent care in structurally gendered health settings exacerbates health care and health inequities for TNB young adults.