We highlight concerns regarding the approval of relugolix for patients with prostate cancer. These include the unsuitable comparator arm and primary endpoint in the HERO trial, as well as potential selection bias and the poor representativeness of the trial population. Dosing adherence to a daily tablet may also be an issue in comparison to injections at 3-mo intervals. Rigorous postmarketing trials of relugolix assessing clinically meaningful endpoints for these patients are needed.