Protein l-isoaspartyl methyltransferase (PIMT/PCMT1), a product of the human pcmt1 gene, catalyzes repair of abnormal l-isoaspartyl linkages in age-damaged proteins. Pcmt1 knock-out mice exhibit a profound neuropathology and die 30-60 days postnatal from an epileptic seizure. Here we express 15 reported variants of human PIMT and characterize them with regard to their enzymatic activity, thermal stability, and propensity to aggregation. One mutation, R36C, renders PIMT completely inactive, whereas two others, A7P and I58V, exhibit activity that is 80-100% higher than wild type. G175R is highly prone to aggregation and has greatly reduced activity. R17S and R17H show markedly enhanced sensitivity to thermal denaturation. Based on previous studies of moderate PIMT variation in humans and mice, we predict that heterozygosity for R36C, G175R, R17S, and R17H will prove detrimental to cognitive function and successful aging, whereas homozygosity (if it ever occurs) will lead to severe neurological problems in the young.