Fusarium wilt, caused by Fusarium oxysporum f. sp. lycopersici (Fol), causes losses in tomato production worldwide, with major impacts on Californian tomato processing. Single-gene resistance is the primary management tool, but its efficacy has been compromised following the emergence of two successive resistance-breaking races, which, in California, emerged within 12 years of resistance deployment. Fol race 3-resistant (F3) processing tomato cultivars (containing the I3 resistance gene) were deployed in the state starting in approximately 2009. The emergence of a new resistance-breaking race (which would be called race 4) is imminent, and early detection will be critical to delay the spread while new resistance is sought. The detection of Fol race 4 is challenged by the lack of validated, rapid, and accurate diagnostic tools. In evaluating in planta phenotyping methods, this study found that rapid seedling phenotyping is not reliable and generates false positives for nonpathogens. Longer (10 weeks) mature plant assays are the most reliable, but may not be sufficiently timely. As an additional challenge, based on field and greenhouse studies, Fol race 3 can cause symptoms in resistant F3 cultivars at frequencies greater (30%) than expected for off-types (<2%). We developed a three-F3 cultivar in planta assay to overcome the challenges this posed to differentiating Fol race 3 and Fol race 4. Using the assay, we determined that all putative resistance-breaking cases were Fol race 3; Fol race 4 was not detected in these early survey efforts. These results highlight the need for developing rapid Fol race 4 detection tools and a better understanding of the factors underlying inconsistent I3 gene expression in Fol race 3.