There is little doubt that examples play a major
role in acquiring a n e w skill. H o w examples improve
learning, however, is subject to some debate. Re-
cently, two different classes of theories have been pro-
posed to explain w h y examples are such an effective
manner of learning. Example Generalization m o d -
els suggest that problem solving rules are acquired
while studying examples. Knowledge Compilation
models, on the other hand, suggest that examples
are useful because they guide future problem solv-
ing, where the necessary rules are created. Consis-
tent with knowledge compilation models, w e found
that separating target problems from source exam-
ples hindered learning because the source exeimples
could not be remembered to guide problem solving.
W e also found that if sources are not accessible or re-
m e m b e r e d during problem solving, learning occurs
best w h e n the sources are problems to be solved,
rather than examples. Taken together, these results
provide strong support for the knowledge compilation
view: in order for an example to be most effective,
the knowledge gained from the example must be ap-
plied to solving a new problem.