- Main
An Examination of Place-Based Structural and Social Determinants of Breastfeeding Among Low-Income Women in Los Angeles County
- Shodahl, Skye
- Advisor(s): Prelip, Michael L
Abstract
Background: Despite ongoing public health efforts, racial/ethnic disparities in breastfeeding remain a major barrier to maternal and child health equity. Minority women (e.g., Black and Hispanic) continue to experience lower breastfeeding rates than White women. Place-based SDOH, such as neighborhood conditions, are well-established determinants of health and may also be relevant to breastfeeding. Although research on their role in breastfeeding remains limited, existing studies have indicated an association that warrants further investigation. This dissertation attempts to address this gap by examining the association between structural and social determinants of health and breastfeeding (initiation, duration, and exclusivity) among low-income women, specifically participants in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program for Woman, Infant, and Children (WIC) living in Los Angeles County. Three interconnected studies were conducted, each focusing on a distinct and understudied aspect of the neighborhood environment. Study 1 provides the most comprehensive assessment by examining how a multidimensional measure of place-based SDOH may help explain individual-level differences in breastfeeding practices. This measure reflects overall neighborhood quality as well as conditions across eight domains: economic, education, social, housing, transportation, neighborhood-built environment, clean environment, and healthcare access. Study 2 is an exploratory examination of how a broad measure of neighborhood racial/ethnic concentration, operationalized as the percentage of Hispanic residents in a neighborhood, may help explain individual-level differences in breastfeeding practices. Lastly, Study 3 examines the association between a neighborhood’s food environment, specifically access to healthy foods, and individual-level breastfeeding practices. Methods: Multilevel data were used throughout each study. The primary datasets include individual-level data from the Los Angeles County WIC Survey (Studies 1-3) and neighborhood-level data from the Healthy Places Index (Study 1), United States Department of Agriculture’s Food Access Research Atlas (Study 3), and the United States Census Bureau’s Decennial Census and Geographic Relationship files (Study 2 and 3, respectively). These datasets were merged across the three studies, in different combinations, to create the multilevel datasets used to examine neighborhood effects on breastfeeding. Given the multilevel nature of the data, all three studies employed multilevel analyses, using mixed models, to account for the nesting of individuals within ZIP codes. Results: Study 1 found that overall neighborhood quality is not associated with breastfeeding outcomes, however domain-specific analyses of neighborhood conditions revealed that the education domain is positively and independently associated with increased initiation, duration (at 3 and 6 months) and exclusivity (at 3 and 6 months) beyond maternal covariates. Additionally, exclusive breastfeeding is the only outcome independently associated with multiple domains (i.e., education, income, and healthcare), with better neighborhood conditions linked to increased initiation, duration (at 3 and 6 months), and exclusivity (at 3 and 6 months) even after adjusting for maternal covariates. Study 2 found that higher neighborhood Hispanic concentration is associated with lower odds of exclusive breastfeeding at 3 and 6 months, even after adjusting for maternal covariates. Study 3 found that the neighborhood food environment, as measured by the percentage of residents in a ZIP-code living in a food desert tract, is not independently associated with breastfeeding beyond maternal covariates. Conclusion: Overall, the findings of this dissertation provide evidence that breastfeeding behaviors are shaped not only by individual-level factors but also by some broader neighborhood contexts. By adopting a place-based approach, this dissertation integrated a contextual dimension to the understanding of breastfeeding inequities that has been largely overlooked in the existing body of research. The dominant individualistic framing of breastfeeding as a personal choice has narrowly placed responsibility on mothers while ignoring the structural inequities that limit their choice to breastfeed. Overlooking these structural forces allows systems that fail mothers to persist and reinforce inequities. Therefore, continuing to grow this body of research is critical to advancing maternal and child health equity by shifting the framing of breastfeeding from an individual choice to one shaped by broader structural conditions.