Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

Theaters of Perversity: The BDSM Sex Economy in New York City

Abstract

Theaters of Perversity explores how dominatrixes and their clients stage fantasies of prostitution, its criminalization, and stigmatization through BDSM sex work. The contemporary sex workers’ rights movement has leveraged a labor-rights framework to advocate for sex work’s decriminalization. While this has been politically effective, it has fallen short of accounting for the sexual dimensions of transactional sex. This is in spite of the fact that it is precisely these sexual dimensions that create the conditions for sex work. Anti-prostitution regulations, whore stigmas, and clients’ desires are all bound up in sexual fantasies of prostitution. In order to understand these fantasies, this dissertation turns to the sexual dramas staged in sessions between dominatrixes and clients. I draw on fifteen months of ethnographic research on the BDSM sex economy in New York City from 2022-2023. During this time, I attended regular shifts at a commercial dungeon, observed sessions with dominatrixes and clients, and participated in dominatrix social gatherings. In the sessions I observed, dominatrixes and clients enacted the ambivalent circumstances that subtend transactional sex: the moral dilemma of sexual objectification, anxieties around commodified intimacy, and the racial-sexual histories of prostitution. Dominatrixes and clients did not attempt to resolve these dramas, but rather enacted them in all their unresolvability. Through this practice, dominatrixes have developed political analyses of transactional sex that begin with its sexual, fantastic, and polymorphously perverse dimensions. Their insights illuminate new ways of approaching both the study and politics of transactional sex. This dissertation also develops a method of perverse ethnography that can attend to the phenomenal dimensions of sexual experience. There was no way to observe BDSM sessions without participating in their fantasy dramas. As such, I performed my research as a persona, who, in time, revealed herself as my own fetish of the voyeuristic anthropologist. Through her, sessions became opportunities for dommes, clients, and me to stage the perversities of the ethnographic encounter and the colonial histories that haunt it. These stagings illuminated not only the structure of BDSM sessions, but also what perversity and fantasy could yield as ethnographic tools.

Main Content

This item is under embargo until September 30, 2027.