Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Merced

UC Merced Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Merced

Inhuman Partisans

Abstract

Recognizing our shared humanity and seeing other people living amidst us as fellow humans is crucial for the functioning of society. Albeit rivalries and cleavages will always exist across civilizations due to human nature, knowing that the oppositions are inherently and irrevocably the same humans as us can often draw a limit to the conflictual confrontations. Nonetheless, history has taught us that mass killings and murders, the supreme acts of evil facilitated by no longer treating people as humans, can still happen from time to time, such as how Nazis treated the Jewish people during World War II. While these instances are generally considered rare events, what if this were to change? What if this notion of depriving oppositions of their humanity becomes so prevalent among the general public that gradually opens doors to normalize the acceptance of extreme acts of violence within an everyday form of conflict that most people experience: politics? Will political competitions that are designed to sustain a healthy democracy spiral into endless cycles of violent polarization that become common and not surprising?

Dehumanization, defined as the denial of full humanness to others, has long been studied in the context of intergroup relations within social psychology (Haslam 2006). From the subtle form of depriving human essence (Haslam and Loughnan 2014; Leyens et al. 2000) to the blatantly animalistic perceptions (Kteily and Bruneau2017b), the very existence of dehumanization has proven to be intimately linked to the darkest side of intergroup conflicts in human nature (D. L. Smith 2020). However, social scientists have only just begun to explore the political implications of dehumanization.

Building on the emerging levels of animosity and discrimination toward out-partisans (Iyengar and Westwood 2015) and the rising level of affective polarization in the United States (Iyengar, Sood, and Lelkes 2012), some recently published studies find that Democrats and Republicans are equally willing to go so far as to dehumanize one another, and this level of dehumanizing perception is associated with the extremeness of partisan identity and the affective distances between the parties (Cassese 2019, 2020; Martherus et al. 2019; Moore-Berg et al. 2020a, 2020b). These findings provide evidence of a new form of psychological mechanism that electorates are willing to go beyond simply disliking out-partisans to the extreme antipathy of dehumanizing out-partisans. This increasing level of polarizing attitudes can be detrimental to the very foundation of democratic institutions (Graham and Svolik 2020; Levitsky and Ziblatt 2018), projecting a dimmer future for the great American democracy.

Why does partisan dehumanization occur? Existing studies in political science seem to implicitly treat it as merely a different function of affective polarization. Yet, neuroscientific evidence proves that dehumanizing perception is indeed a distinct construct as compared to common negative or prejudicial attitudes that drive affective polarization (Bruneau et al. 2018). As a result, other than establishing its robust empirical association with extreme partisanship and ideology, the causes and consequences of partisan dehumanization remain largely unexplored. Also, if affective polarization and partisan dehumanization are such unwelcome phenomena that we should seek to avoid, why are the American partisans still embracing partyism and even willing to justify violent behaviors toward the other side (Kalmoe and Mason 2022)?

In my dissertation, I argue that extreme attitudes and dehumanizing perceptions serve as cognitive mechanisms to satisfy a basic human need: the pursuit of happiness. As politics becomes more complex nowadays (Lupia 2016), yet easier to access at the same time (Bakshy, Messing, and Adamic 2015), to prevent themselves from feeling stressed and discouraged when navigating through the complicated political world, the political hobbyists (Hersh 2020) among us gradually become more extreme to enjoy being part of politics. At the same time, dehumanizing perceptions emerge as a cognitive function to justify schadenfreude in the political arena, which brings more joy to the partisans and further intensifies the cycle of polarization. In short, in responding to the more complicated political world, partisans equipped with a stronger identity and dehumanizing perceptions toward their opponents are simply better at playing and enjoying the political games.

This dissertation proceeds in three parts to scrutinize the prominence of partisan dehumanization in the contemporary United States. The first part outlines the main theoretical arguments that at the individual level, extreme attitudes and dehumanizing perceptions can allow partisans to generate more positive attitudes in politics. Utilizing data from a continuous diary study and an experiment designed to elicit dehumanization, the empirical results provide tentative evidence that corroborates the theoretical expectations. The second part offers a set of novel measurements for partisan dehumanization with lab and survey experiments, drawing insights from social psychology and behavioral game theory. As compared to plainly using self-reported survey scales, I suggest these measures can grant us richer facets of dehumanization. The third part focuses on the contextual element: how partisan segregation correlates with the degree of partisan dehumanization. Using a nationally representative survey and multilevel regression with poststratification, this part presents state-level estimations that indicate how environmental factors can also interact with dehumanizing attitudes.