Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

L2 Journal

L2 Journal bannerUC Berkeley

Chatting with Claude: From Information Exchange to Intellectual Seduction 

Creative Commons 'BY-NC-ND' version 4.0 license
Abstract

This essay reports on the author's sessions with a chatbot, first to identify birds and then to edit photographs for printing, and considers what they suggest for foreign language learning. Where answers could be checked against a field guide, the chatbot's efficiency invited cognitive offloading, depriving the learner of the incidental discoveries that come with paging through a reference work. Where they could not be checked, offloading extended to interpretation itself, and the chatbot's sycophancy, no longer checked by an outside authority, shaped the exchange in ways that were harder to detect and to resist. The essay sets these observations beside research on chatbots in language education, where the findings of SLA and cognitive science research diverge. Finally, the essay addresses the question of what a fluent chatbot cannot offer learners hoping to understand what it means to speak, feel, and imagine in another culture.