Structural Racism, the Criminal-Legal System, and Racial/Ethnic Inequities in Adverse Maternal Health Outcomes
- Hailu, Elleni Menberu
- Advisor(s): Mujahid, Mahasin S
Abstract
Persistent racial/ethnic inequities in maternal health outcomes are an urgent public health concern in the United States. Black birthing people are more likely to die of childbirth and to experience severe pregnancy-related complications than White birthing people. Other birthing people of color also have an elevated risk of adverse maternal health outcomes compared to White individuals. Of particular concern are alarming racial/ethnic inequities in severe maternal morbidity (SMM), a set of severe organ-system dysfunctions that may occur during childbirth. Black birthing people are estimated to have a 2-3-fold higher risk of SMM than their White counterparts. Despite recent encouraging efforts, little research examines the structural determinants of these inequities. One such structural driver that may be at the root of these inequities is structural racism—a fundamental cause of racial/ethnic health inequities, defined as the totality of ways through which racist policies and practices work together to disenfranchise racially/ethnically marginalized individuals. Structural racism patterns the distribution of material/psychosocial stressors and assets contributing to health and well-being. However, the link between structural racism and inequities in maternal health outcomes, specifically SMM, remains under-investigated, and there is a need for theoretical and methodological advancement in existing work. Furthermore, research on the manifestation of structural racism within the criminal-legal system and its connection to SMM, and racial/ethnic disparities in SMM is limited. The overall goal of this dissertation is to help address these gaps by assessing how structural racism is related to maternal health outcomes broadly and, more particularly, how its manifestation through the criminal-legal system may shape SMM risk.
Chapter 1 offers a novel conceptual framework that outlines how structural racism influences racial/ethnic inequities in pregnancy-related outcomes and systematically reviews the current epidemiologic literature on markers of structural racism and their relation to adverse maternal health outcomes. This review highlights a limited set of studies investigating this link and finds that based on the population sub-groups analyzed, measures used, and covariates considered, there is evidence that structural racism is associated with a higher risk of pregnancy-related complications. It also discusses several areas for methodological and theoretical development in this body of work.
Chapter 2 examines law-enforcement violence as one manifestation of structural racism in relation to SMM. It assesses the link between the occurrence of fatal police violence within a birthing person’s neighborhood before/during pregnancy and subsequent SMM risk. It uses data from hospital discharge and vital statistics records between 2002 and 2018 from California linked with the Fatal Encounters database. It also investigates differential associations based on the frequency of fatal police violence in a person’s neighborhood. Although evidence from this study was inconclusive, estimates suggest that the occurrence of such events within the preceding 24 months of childbirth may be associated with a slightly increased risk of SMM, particularly within neighborhoods where such adverse events are less frequent. This study highlights the need to continue to examine population-level adverse health implications of police violence.
Chapter 3 focuses on the carceral system as a domain of structural racism. It uses Black-White inequity in county jail incarceration as an indicator of structural racism and investigates its link with SMM. Data for this study are from hospital discharge and vital statistics records from California between 1997 and 2018 linked with the Vera Institute of Justice Incarceration Trends dataset. This study finds that for Non-Hispanic Black, Hispanic/Latinx, and Non-Hispanic White birthing people, residing in counties with greater inequities in jail incarceration rates is associated with increased risk of SMM, after accounting for individual-level characteristics and county-level socio-economic status. In addition, associations were stronger for Non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic/Latinx individuals. Findings from this study highlight the need to address the adverse maternal health consequences of structural racism manifesting via the criminal-legal system. They also provide evidence for community-based alternatives to inequitable punitive practices.
Given persistent and alarming racial/ethnic gaps in adverse maternal health outcomes, we must continue to interrogate structural racism and address its lasting implications on health. This approach is necessary in order to implement effective strategies, policies, and interventions that help alleviate these inequities. As such, this dissertation contributes important insights into how structural racism may be related to racial/ethnic inequities in pregnancy-related complications, with a particular focus on the criminal-legal system and SMM.