We examine the range of validity of the Gaussian model for various water-like liquids whose intermolecular potentials differ from SPC/E water, to provide insight into the temperature dependence of the hydrophobic effect for small hard sphere solutes. We find that low compressibility liquids that have more close-packed network structures show much larger deviations from Gaussian fluctuations for low or zero occupancies relative to more compressible fluids with more open networks. Water appears to be a unique molecular fluid in possessing equilibrium density fluctuations that are faithfully described by the Gaussian theory. We ascribe this success to the fact, shown here, that the orientational correlations near a small hard sphere solute involve remarkably little reorganization from the bulk, which is a consequence of water's low solvent reorganization enthalpy and entropy.

We measure the solvation free energy, Δμ*, for hard spheres and Lennard-Jones particles in a number of artificial liquids made from modified water models. These liquids have reduced hydrogen bond strengths or altered bond angles. By measuring Δμ* for a number of state points at P = 1 bar and different temperatures, we obtain solvation entropies and enthalpies, which are related to the temperature dependence of the solubilities. By resolving the solvation entropy into the sum of the direct solute-solvent interaction and a term depending on the solvent reorganisation enthalpy we show that, although the hydrophobic effect in water at 300 K arises mainly from the small molecular size, its temperature dependence is anomalously low because the reorganisation enthalpy of liquid water is unusually small. We attribute this to the strong tetrahedral network which results from both the molecular geometry and the hydrogen bond strength.