Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

The Imperial Lightning Rod: Competing Visions of Race and Labor among Colonial Kenya's Failed Settlement Schemes, 1870-1939

Abstract

The racialized political economy of British East Africa (today Kenya) was based upon a precarious foundation of unsustainable land speculation. Meanwhile, what production occurred depended upon the labor of Africans who were often forced to sell their labor or squat on European estates. Thus, the glamorous “Happy Valley” image which typified colonial Kenya was a precarious illusion sustained by generations of land speculation, colonial violence, and forced labor. This dissertation analyzes how this illusion was constructed and reconfigured by examining as cultural artifacts the many failed attempts by people around the world to profitably annex, subdivide, and allocate land in colonial Kenya. These failed settlement schemes were acts of economic as well as cultural speculation. Each settlement scheme was its own act of imaginative worldbuilding, an attempt to imagine a new colonial society. These societies varied widely from a Zionist state in the Kenyan highlands, to a fully mechanized socialist utopia, to an aristocratic society of masters and servants, to a confederation of agricultural cooperatives and beyond, each a testament to the breadth of visions and fantasies which could be projected upon a single British settler colony. Some were proposed sincerely, some were merely confidence tricks, yet all these imaginary societies reflected the political economy they hoped to (re)shape. Yet as the lands available for speculation dwindled and the white settler population proved itself an unreliable partner for the colonial state, the form of the settlement schemes changed from more utopian visions of expansive new settler states to a more laundered, developmental vision of white settlement which was calibrated to assure the colonial state that the failing project of white settlement deserved further public support despite ongoing anticolonial resistance and economic depression. Read together, colonial Kenya’s expansive archive of failed settlement schemes demonstrates the protean nature of whiteness in the ‘white man’s country’ and how definitions of whiteness, imperial citizenship, and development were constantly reconfigured as the colony’s speculative political economy evolved.