Buried Seeds: Women of Color Leaders in Student Affairs Managing the Interplay of Free Speech and Inclusion
Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

Buried Seeds: Women of Color Leaders in Student Affairs Managing the Interplay of Free Speech and Inclusion

Abstract

Women of color (WOC) leaders in student affairs are at the nexus of the interplay of free speech and inclusion. However, this phenomena has been rarely researched and their roles have been often ignored. This descriptive study examined how WOC leaders in student affairs, who managed the interplay, used their role to influence their institution’s commitment to equity and inclusion. Ten WOC leaders with at least 10 years of experience from institutions across the United States participated in the study, with each participating in one 60-minute Zoom interview. Findings showed WOC made dynamic shifts to adjust for structural racism’s inequities; WOC interwove knowledge, skills, and support as their grounding; and WOC approaches included practicing, sensemaking, and embodying the interplay. A final finding showed successful interplay management needed systemic support of institutions. Factors impeding the work included systemic barriers that caused heightened values misalignment for the WOC due to disproportionate racialized and gendered harm. WOC preparation to manage the interplay included understanding disproportionate impact on marginalized communities, ensuring students feel supported, and building support systems. WOC managed the interplay by learning, reflecting, and acting with equity. Institutions need to systemically support WOC’s leadership and student learning to commit to equity and inclusion. Conclusions showed WOC relationships are key and confirmed free speech policies are raced and the interplay is gendered and racialized labor. Institutions’ embeddedness of structural racism affected the interplay, and as such, neutrality does not exist in nonneutral institutions. Finally, without distributing power among administrators, faculty, and staff, inequities are perpetuated. Recommendations surface the need for strategic mitigation of inequities perpetuated by systemic racism and surfaced through the interplay. Considerations for WOC, cabinet-level leaders, and systemic practices include institutionalizing support systems for WOC, reframing an institutional approach to the interplay to give WOC experts control, embracing an equitable shared governance structure, and challenging the presumption of institutional neutrality. Together, the implications, conclusions, and recommendation for future research, paint a robust picture of the importance of these women’s roles in impacting policies, practices, and systems within higher education.