Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Santa Barbara

UC Santa Barbara Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Santa Barbara

Student-Centered Factors as Predictors for Learning and Motivation in Digital Games: Examining a Deception Detection Training Game

  • Author(s): Adams, Aubrie Serena
  • Advisor(s): Dunbar, Norah E.
  • et al.
Abstract

Early scholars in the field of game studies praised digital games for their potential to impact teaching and learning processes; however, this one-size-fits all approach to games in education may not effectively improve learning for all types of students. Their interests, beliefs, goals, needs, and knowledge (which can be called student-centered factors) may play a role in their ability to learn from a game-based training. The goal of this dissertation is to examine the conditions in which learners are more likely to benefit from a digital training game. Rather than manipulating the features of a game to examine the impact on students, the current study examines the students themselves.

To examine the degree that pre-existing student-centered factors can be used to predict a person’s likelihood of learning and motivation in digital game-based training, a sequential mixed-methods design was utilized in which both qualitative and quantitative data were gathered in three different data collection stages. Study I (Chapter III) utilized a survey method to pilot test the instrumentation that was designed to measure five student-centered factors of interest in this study. Study II (Chapter IV) was exploratory and used both focus group and interview methods to examine participant experiences after play-testing an alpha version of a digital learning game, VERITAS. Study III (Chapter V) used a pretest-posttest experimental design to assess the degree that student-centered factors impact learning between two types of training conditions and assessed the degree that student-centered factors predict four types of motivation (outcome-focused, process-focused, means-focused, and intrinsic motivation).

Five key findings summarize the most notable outcomes of this research: first, the game-based training contributes to higher levels of learning in comparison to a PowerPoint lecture-based training; this is especially the case for learners who report that English is not their first language. Second, having a stronger interest in the topic of deception detection is positively related to perceptions of enjoyment and value (intrinsic motivation) in the game-based training. Third, having a stronger belief in one’s ability to learn about the topic of deception detection is negatively related to one’s experience in attending to goals (process-focused motivation); but is positively related to perceptions of competence in the game-based training. Fourth, having a goal that is oriented toward mastering a topic is negatively related to the effort that a user reports putting into the training game. Lastly, having needs that are more likely to be satisfied in digital games is positively related to asking more in-game questions in a game-based training (means-focused motivation); but is negatively related to one’s perceptions of value in the training.

From a new media perspective, this research explores the affordances and limitations of games in education. Findings overall show that users are likely to interact with a digital learning tool based on their own unique prior experiences. By seeking to understand the relationship between student-centered factors, learning, and motivation, scholars can better design games to serve diverse students in our evolving digital age.

Main Content
For improved accessibility of PDF content, download the file to your device.
Current View