Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Santa Cruz

UC Santa Cruz Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Santa Cruz

Report on the Replication of Shinn & Blumstein (1984)

Creative Commons 'BY-SA' version 4.0 license
Abstract

This study examines how American English listeners use two temporal parameters, amplitude rise time (ART) and transition duration (TD), to diagnose consonant manner, replicating previous work on the /b/-/w/ contrast (Shinn & Blumstein, 1984). A tripartite free response pattern is found, replicating stop and approximant responses at fast-ART, fast-TD, and slow-ART, slow-TD regions of the stimulus space, respectively, and replicating critical fricative responses in the slow-ART, fast-TD region of the stimulus space. This confirms that listeners do not require frication to report hearing fricatives. However, likely due to changes in synthesis parameters, we fail to replicate the original categorization responses, and find approximant responses in the fast-ART, slow-TD region of the stimulus space, akin to the results of Walsh & Diehl (1991), where the original experiment finds stop responses. Taken together, these results present a complex –if early– picture about the role of periodic information in manner perception.