In the Cities and on the Road: Tournaments, Wrestler Status, and Standardization of Sumo as Commercialized Entertainment in Early Modern Japan, 1600–1850
Abstract
In this dissertation, “In the Cities and on the Road: Tournaments, Wrestler Status, and Standardization of Sumo as Commercialized Entertainment in Early Modern Japan, 1600–1850,” I analyze sumo wrestling as a form of urban culture and public entertainment during the Edo period (1603–1868), focusing on its performances both inside and outside major cities. I place the development of sumo within the larger context of urban growth and the expansion of regulations, examining the cultural shift away from rural influence, and highlighting how urban centers increasingly became the originators of cultural trends rather than just recipients.I argue that the rise of professional sumo wrestling and its integration into the broader entertainment industry were deeply intertwined with the emergence of early modern urban culture between the 1600s and the mid-1800s. This period witnessed the consolidation of sumo as a formalized performance culture, marked by the establishment of standardized tournament formats by the late seventeenth century and the formation of monopolistic wrestler groups. The increasing scale and scope of sumo events in the following decades reflected broader socio-political and economic developments.In particular, I trace the transformation in the social status of wrestlers—from feudal retainers to freelance performers—within a landscape shaped by urban and religious authorities. I contend that sumo wrestlers navigated these changes more flexibly than performers in other entertainment sectors. Their ability to implement systems of licensing and self-governance was key to sustaining sumo’s popularity and financial viability in the rapidly expanding urban centers of the eighteenth century.This dissertation is organized into four chapters. Chapter One provides a historical overview of early modern urban and rural entertainment cultures. It focuses on the core structures of Kabuki, Noh, and otoshi-banashi performances, analyzing their distinctive characteristics alongside the socioeconomic, legal, and political conditions that shaped them. Special attention is given to issues related to itinerancy, originating from the fundraising campaigns of the so-called hijiri entertainers, which culminated during the height of urban public staged entertainment in the 1800s.Chapters Two and Three work together to explore the lives of itinerant sumo wrestlers in the cities of Edo, Osaka, and Kyoto, as well as on the road, between 1600 and 1850. The chapters highlight the significant role of non-urban events in standardizing sumo wrestling in the eighteenth century. Chapter Two analyzes the structural and social-political factors that enabled the development of sumo’s self-governing system and the creation of a nationwide event schedule by the 1750s. It also examines the state-sponsored exhibition tournaments, introduced in 1791 for the shogun, which helped legitimize the Edo-based Yoshida family’s authority and contributed to the formalization of sumo performance practices. Chapter Three focuses on how the sumo elders under the Yoshida further expanded their influence by issuing licenses to locals, thereby promoting regional representation beyond Edo by the early 1800s. Their licensing system allowed wrestlers to travel to regional centers and seek employment and patronage from local feudal lords. Case studies from the three domains of Tosa, Morioka, and Matsue show the dynamic cultural exchange between the major cities and cultural centers of the non-urban regions.Chapter Four presents detailed case studies of two wrestlers employed in Matsue, Raiden Tame’emon 雷電為衛門 and Inazuma Raigorō 稲妻雷五郎, to explore the experiences and social status of itinerant wrestlers during the Edo period. Drawing on personal records from 1804, this chapter reconstructs the conditions of traveling wrestlers, the structure and context of individual tournaments, and the preparations involved. It argues that groups of traveling wrestlers acted as cultural emissaries, disseminating a distinctive sumo culture to more remote areas. The chapter concludes with an analysis of how the social status of sumo wrestlers evolved until the early nineteenth century.The dissertation concludes by summarizing the state of sumo wrestling as urban entertainment around 1850. In doing so, it offers a historical perspective that complements existing scholarship in Western languages on the modernization of sumo wrestling.