Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

A Book Review Made out of Whole Cloth

  • Author(s): Read, Dwight W
  • et al.
Abstract

 A good book review provides documentation for its evaluations, especially when they are either very positive or very negative. A good review is also faithful to what the author has written and bases criticisms or praise on accurate paraphrasing or quotes from the book. This review by Thompson fails on both accounts. Critical comments are not documented and the review is based on what Thompson imagines Read to have written, not what Read actually wrote.

Main Content
Current View