Shí Naashá: Land and Sovereignty in the Navajo Nation
Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

Shí Naashá: Land and Sovereignty in the Navajo Nation

Abstract

This dissertation examines the question of land and its relationship to sovereignty in the Navajo Nation. I argue that to understand contemporary questions related to land in the Navajo Nation, such as issues surrounding natural resource extraction, it is necessary to understand land as an historical product. The overarching question is, how have Diné people conceptualized land at different moments as a strategic response to settler colonial transformations in their lives? I explore this question through the frameworks of Marxist geography, critical Indigenous studies, and agrarian studies. The overarching question is further disaggregated to three figures of soil, sheep, and fences to ask questions of different historical conjunctures in Diné worlds. Through soil, I ask, how did scientific practices of soil and moisture conservation set the preconditions for broader transformations in land? Through sheep, I ask, how did ideas of improvement alter relationships to land through processes of rug commodification? Through fences, I ask, how did practices of partition and fencing during the so-called Navajo-Hopi land dispute contribute to emerging Diné subjectivities that expressed kinship with a global dispossessed? I engage with Diné critique to understand how, at different moments, Diné analyzed the conditions of their dispossession. Through engagement with these critiques, I offer an understanding of Dinéness that is produced in concrete moments as relationships to land are transformed.