Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Davis

UC Davis Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Davis

Determination of Variation in Forensic Ethanol Analysis Results Using a Deuterated Internal Standard for Samples Collected at the Lower Limit of Sufficient Volume for Analysis: A Cost Benefit Perspective

Abstract

Forensic alcohol analysis of ante-mortem blood samples is a common service performed in many laboratories across the country. 1-Propanol is a commonly used internal standard for the detection and quantification of ethanol in these samples. Ethanol-d6 could potentially be a more reliable internal standard due to sharing a similar structure and vapor pressure to ethanol and because it would also be similarly affected by outside factors as ethanol. However, ethanol-d6 is more expensive and its use may require adjusting the parameters of a gas chromatograph to achieve adequate separation from ethanol for quantitation by flame ionization detection (FID). In this study, aqueous ethanol samples were individually spiked with either 1-propanol or ethanol-d6 and run through a headspace GC-MS to quantify the concentration of ethanol present and to compare the results between the two internal standards. Samples drawn from 0.080 g/dL ethanol solutions of various sodium fluoride and potassium oxalate salt concentrations were also spiked with the internal standards, run, and compared to test the salting-out effect on the internal standards. This study found that while 1-propanol was more accurate than ethanol-d6 in the salt-free samples, ethanol-d6 was more accurate when salts were present. It also found that 1-propanol was more precise at lower ethanol concentrations while ethanol-d6 was more precise at higher concentrations. However, ethanol-d6 is over 300 times more expensive than 1-propanol on a cost per run basis, so this may outweigh any potential improvements in assay performance.