Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

An Investigation into Student Development from STEM Undergraduate Research Experiences Through a Focus on Teaching and Mentoring Practices

Abstract

My dissertation features an overview of 3 studies relating to the Berkeley Undergraduate Research Evaluations Tools (BURET) project. The BURET project was initiated to develop qualitative and quantitative research tools and protocols to evaluate how learning and mentorship are being experienced by undergraduate students who are involved in faculty laboratory research. The BURET project was also tasked with answering the following three questions: 1) What do undergraduate researchers learn about scientific content and research practices? 2) What practices do graduate students and post-docs report using when teaching and mentoring undergraduate researchers? 3) What teaching and mentoring practices do undergraduates report in their research experiences? I have carried out three studies that together focus on research impacts in the K-12 classroom, measurement of student mentoring and teaching in undergraduate research experiences (UREs), and analysis of interventions carried out towards mentorship training and coaching of chemistry graduate students. My research studies expand upon the original scope of the BURET project. At a broader level, my goal is to provide insight into the experience of learning and engaging in chemistry and the impacts of said engagement at later career stages for students.The first study I have worked on for the BURET project was a collaboration with the CalTeach program at my institution where I investigated which teaching practices used by K-12 STEM teachers were influenced by the undergraduate research experiences they participated in as pre-service teachers in the CalTeach program and in what ways undergraduate research experiences have affected the instruction or attitudes towards teaching in STEM. Data collected were interview transcripts from the teachers about how research influences their teaching, and analysis was carried out through descriptive assessments and coding. We developed our own coding scheme based on several educational frameworks and the Next Generation Science Standards. From our coding analysis, we obtained findings that indicate that teachers attributed improvements towards their competency, confidence, and qualifications to teach as a result of participating in UREs. Participating in UREs helped teachers better engage their students in the conceptual (understanding scientific knowledge and contexts, modeling, and planning and carrying out investigations) aspects of scientific investigations, along with social (collaboration, communication, and evaluation of scientific information and results) aspects. Teachers found that engaging in UREs also helped them to connect lessons focused on scientific inquiry with applications that are relevant to the students and their communities.The second study is focused on the BURET Teaching and Mentoring in URE Survey (BURET-TAMUS). Here, I developed and administered a survey to measure teaching practices, mentoring practices, and other aspects of the URE experience that undergraduate students experience while conducting STEM research. This was done to gain more insight on what integration of teaching and mentoring practices students feel are helpful towards their development and also to see if the extent of teaching and mentoring practices in UREs is influenced by other research factors. Construct Response Modeling was used as a foundation to build the survey instrument and several statistical models were employed to fit and analyze the survey data. We aim to use our data to study the multidimensionality of the teaching and mentoring constructs that we have defined and the latent variables that might be influencing them in UREs. Results indicate that undergraduate students in our sample who have research experience report high levels of support in terms of achieving research goals and social engagement (feedback, communication, and early project guidance) from their research mentors, but we found that the research factors that we tested for in BURET-TAMUS didn’t seem to have much correlation with each other or some teaching and mentoring practices.The third study featured in this dissertation is the development and execution of the BURET Bring out the Best in Your Undergraduate Researcher Workshop Series. This workshop series trains graduate students at UC Berkeley on how to work with and support undergraduate students conducting research in faculty labs. Over the course of several weeks, participants completed activities and engaged with workshop topics that are meant to help research mentors implement and plan their approach towards teaching and mentoring of undergraduate researchers. We emphasized the importance of effective mentorship and teaching of students through several educational and sociological frameworks to the workshop attendees. At the end of the workshop series, I recruited pairs of graduate students and undergraduate researchers working together in research for a study where I investigated how teaching and mentoring changed as a result of participating in workshop series and whether or not coaching could enhance the teaching and mentoring that graduate students were doing. The investigation was carried out via analysis of recorded interactions and materials submitted to the research team of a teaching or mentoring moment that occurred during their research experiences and through dedicated 1 on 1 coaching sessions with me. To see what was translating from the workshops and how teaching and mentoring was changing over time, we developed and utilized two instruments: BURET-CoTaM and BURET-NASER. The results indicated that much of the workshop content was being applied to actual teaching and mentoring practice by research mentors and that coaching sessions were helpful in getting research mentors to reflect on their approach, try new practices, and be comfortable discussing their teaching and mentoring.From working on the BURET projects, I have been able to connect and work with students from many different backgrounds and experience levels. I have learned new ways to approach teaching and mentorship in the classroom and in the research lab. I have gained skills to evaluate student learning and to reflect on my own teaching and mentoring. Through the interdisciplinary nature of my work, I have been trained to gather evidence that can be used to support chemistry students at other institutions and I hope to continue making contributions to student outreach and chemistry education.