- Main
Women as Legal Actors in Early Islamic Law: Settlement and Dispute Resolution in Practice
Published Web Location
https://doi.org/10.5070/N4.70346Abstract
This Article examines women’s legal agency in peacebuilding and dispute resolution in early Islamic history. Anchored in Qur’anic commitments to justice and reconciliation (sulh) and in the Sunnah as lived institutional practice, it traces how early Muslim communities drew on and reshaped prevailing Arabian dispute-resolution norms, including consultation (shura/mushawara), arbitration (tahkim), and informal mediation. The Article then identifies the socio-legal constraints that limited women’s participation as juristic discourse developed, including gendered assumptions about authority and credibility that were later naturalized as doctrine. Through two case studies, Umm Salama and Aisha bint Abu Bakr, it shows women acting as advisers, mediators, and public reasoners at moments when communal cohesion and legitimacy were under strain, even within patriarchal structures. Situating these episodes within Islamic legal and ethical reasoning, the paper argues that women’s contributions were not marginal to the legal order but part of the architecture through which peace was made and maintained. For feminist readers, the intervention is direct: what looks like “religious tradition” is often the product of contestable interpretive choices. The early record preserves resources for an analysis of gender, authority, and inclusion that does not treat women’s exclusion as inevitable.