Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UCLA Journal of Islamic and Near Eastern Law

UCLA Journal of Islamic and Near Eastern Law bannerUCLA

About

JINEL's goal is to emphasize and critically analyze all legal issues—social, political, civil, historical, economic and commercial—that are of particular relevance to Muslims and Near Easterners in both Muslim and non-Muslim societies.

Article

  • Women as Legal Actors in Early Islamic Law: Settlement and Dispute Resolution in Practice

    This Article examines women’s legal agency in peacebuilding and dispute resolution in early Islamic history. Anchored in Qur’anic commitments to justice and reconciliation (sulh) and in the Sunnah as lived institutional practice, it traces how early Muslim communities drew on and reshaped prevailing Arabian dispute-resolution norms, including consultation (shura/mushawara), arbitration (tahkim), and informal mediation. The Article then identifies the socio-legal constraints that limited women’s participation as juristic discourse developed, including gendered assumptions about authority and credibility that were later naturalized as doctrine. Through two case studies, Umm Salama and Aisha bint Abu Bakr, it shows women acting as advisers, mediators, and public reasoners at moments when communal cohesion and legitimacy were under strain, even within patriarchal structures. Situating these episodes within Islamic legal and ethical reasoning, the paper argues that women’s contributions were not marginal to the legal order but part of the architecture through which peace was made and maintained. For feminist readers, the intervention is direct: what looks like “religious tradition” is often the product of contestable interpretive choices. The early record preserves resources for an analysis of gender, authority, and inclusion that does not treat women’s exclusion as inevitable.

Articles

  • Epistemic Violence in the 2003 Iraq War: A Reflection on Its Legal, Political, and Social Consequences

    In March 2003, the United States and its allies initiated a war on Iraq, resulting in the occupation of the country and approximately half a million deaths. Many intellectuals, including some Iraqi exiles in the United States, alongside the American administration, advisors, and press, provided moral arguments to justify the invasion of Iraq. This dissertation examines the epistemic violence that manifested through the manipulation and distortion of knowledge, information, and discourse to rationalize the denial of a nation-state’s legitimacy in the international law arena. It illuminates how epistemic violence—through constructed narratives and discourse—preceded, accompanied, and prolonged the physical violence inflicted upon Iraq, shaping realities, justifying war, and instigating deep societal divides. Today, undoubtedly, the questioning of the rules-based international order or international law is directly related to this violence of the invasion of Iraq.

  • Islamic Banking in Perspective: Definition, Operation, and Comparison with Conventional Banks

    This paper delves into the principles and operational framework of Islamic banking, contrasting it with conventional banking practices. Islamic banking, rooted in shari’a law and ethical principles, encompasses not only the prohibition of interest but also a broader commitment to fairness, risk-sharing, and societal welfare. It operates under the guidance of shari’a supervisory boards, ensuring compliance with Islamic law in all financial activities. Unlike conventional banking, Islamic finance emphasizes partnership and cooperation between depositors and entrepreneurs, promoting investment in socially beneficial projects and minimizing exploitation. Central to Islamic banking is the concept of risk-sharing, which fosters a more equitable distribution of financial outcomes compared to conventional lending practices. Moreover, Islamic banks prioritize social responsibility through mechanisms such as zakat and ethical investment criteria, contributing to the reduction of income inequality and the promotion of economic justice. This abstract highlights Islamic banking as a holistic approach to finance that integrates religious values with modern financial systems, offering a viable alternative that resonates with the beliefs and principles of millions worldwide. As the global Islamic finance market continues to grow, Islamic banking stands as a testament to the compatibility of religious principles with contemporary economic practices, emphasizing ethics, fairness, and societal welfare.

  • Exploring the Oxymoron: Migrants, Minorities, and Human Rights in the Gulf States

    The oil-driven monarchies of the Persian Gulf maintain diversity and accommodation frameworks that are radically different from European or other liberal States. Firstly, in the member States of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) governance is assumed by the ruling families and follows tribal patterns and elite-based dynamics, excluding representation of social and ethnic groups that are alien to the prevailing tribal framework. Secondly, there are generalized distinctions between citizens and non-citizens, including in the legal sphere and the enjoyment of socio-economic rights. Even so, populations throughout the GCC are becoming increasingly diverse, in terms of ethnicities and nationalities, and a ‘second home’ to a number of expatriates of different religions, traditions, languages, identities, and ways of life. This de facto diversity is precisely the oxymoron that this paper aims at exploring: the fact that GCC States, while still in many respects restrictive in terms of fundamental rights, they are also in other respects flexible and extremely accommodating.