UC Santa Cruz

Hatcheries can support salmon fisheries but also impact natural populations. We model the proportional hatchery contributions to ocean catch, natural-area spawning, and egg production based on hatchery production, maturation, fecundity, and straying. We develop indices of hatchery-origin catch per stray spawner measuring the trade-off between supplementing harvest and limiting natural-area impacts; higher values indicate success in increasing hatchery ocean harvest contributions relative to strays spawning in natural areas. Hatchery fish maturing early lowers catch per stray (and proportion hatchery-origin catch) by shifting the age distributions of both catch and spawners toward younger ages. Age-dependent fecundity may complicate predicted effects of changing maturation schedules. Increased straying does not affect catch but increases hatchery-origin spawning and decreases catch per stray. Differences in hatchery production affect hatchery contributions to both catch and spawning, exacerbating the trade-off between these conflicting goals but with no net effect on catch per stray. Fishery intensity magnifies the effects of accelerated hatchery fish maturation by reducing spawning contributions of older fish, with contrasting effects depending on whether hatchery fish mature early versus late.