Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

Recent Work

The Center for the Study of Child Care Employment focuses on issues relating to the nearly half a million teachers currently employed in some 115,000 regulated child care centers and the estimated 1.8 million workers, including paid relatives, who care for children in home-based settings in the United States. Through its research, policy analysis and development, its aims to improve child care jobs and services.

Cover page of Analysis of Labor Organizing, Unionization, and Collective Bargaining Strategies for the ECE Workforce

Analysis of Labor Organizing, Unionization, and Collective Bargaining Strategies for the ECE Workforce

(2026)

This publication is part of CSCCE’s Student Paper Series and was produced in conjunction with the UC Berkeley Labor Center by students in the course Challenges and Innovations in Labor Policy, offered through the Goldman School of Public Policy at the University of California, Berkeley. Using case studies from California and New Mexico, law students Dalton A. Valerio and Sam Goity explore possibilities for states interested in entering into bargaining relationships with representative entities for the early care and education workforce; present successful strategies for organizing the workforce; and offer guidance for worker advocacy groups and individuals seeking to improve conditions in the ECE sector.

Cover page of Early Educator Voices: OREGON–Work Environment Conditions That Impact Early Educator Practice and Program Quality

Early Educator Voices: OREGON–Work Environment Conditions That Impact Early Educator Practice and Program Quality

(2026)

Early educators are the key to quality early care and education (ECE) services, and there is broad consensus that high-quality care and learning environments for young children depend on educators who are skilled at nurturing children’s development and learning. Yet, inadequate working conditions and low pay routinely hamper educators in their efforts to apply effective teaching and caregiving practices (Institute of Medicine and National Research Council, 2015; McLean et al., 2021). Early educator work environments have a direct impact on their teaching practice, ongoing skill development, and general well-being, yet work environments have routinely been overlooked in quality improvement efforts. Transforming the way that the early care and education system values and supports the working conditions of early educators requires sustained strategies on multiple levels.

As a part of ongoing efforts to transform Spark, Oregon’s quality recognition and improvement system (QRIS), Oregon reached out to the Center for the Study of Child Care Employment (CSCCE) for our assistance to better understand the work environments of the more than 12,000 early educators who offer services for the state's 269,000 children under the age of six (Annie E. Casey Foundation, 2022a). Oregon’s ECE system includes some 1,200 center-based programs and more than 2,000 home-based family child care (FCC) programs (Oregon Department of Education’s Early Learning Division [ELD], 2021). Similar to other states throughout the nation, Oregon is facing a child care crisis, particularly for infants and toddlers. Families with infants and/or toddlers in every county experience a child care desert, with an estimated eight infants and toddlers for every available child care slot (Pratt & Sektnan, 2021). The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated the lack of available care in Oregon (Pears et al., 2021).

In the winter of 2022, CSCCE had the opportunity to survey educators employed in both center- and home-based programs throughout the state of Oregon about their working environments. This was the first CSCCE study utilizing the SEQUAL tool to capture the experiences of FCC providers and their staff and also the first SEQUAL study to examine working conditions after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. This report examines the results of the SEQUAL survey across settings and roles of early educators in Oregon and was commissioned by the Oregon Early Learning Division in order to inform their quality improvement efforts.

Cover page of Teachers of Preschool-Age Children in California

Teachers of Preschool-Age Children in California

(2026)

Early care and education (ECE) programs for children prior to kindergarten in California are provided through a mixed delivery system that includes licensed home- and center-based programs as well as school settings. Parents make decisions about what type of program(s) their children attend based on a combination of factors such as culturally affirmative practices, cost, schedule, and location. Most ECE services must be purchased by parents; public funding is limited, and if subsidized access to early care and education is available, it is typically linked to income eligibility. As a result, many children who qualify for ECE don’t have access. Furthermore, the financial resources available to a program often depend on what families can afford to pay, not necessarily the true costs to provide services.

The requirements, experience, and supports for educators vary widely across settings, depending more on funding sources and regulatory status and less on what educators and children may need. This situation is typical across the ECE system for children from infancy through preschool, though California has made substantial changes in providing preschool for four-year-olds. Transitional Kindergarten (TK) was introduced into this mix in the 2012-13 school year. As of the 2022-23 school year, TK became the only free, universal ECE program in California available for four-year-olds. In this brief, we compare the experiences of educators who lead their respective classrooms.

Cover page of Bold on Early Educator Compensation Learning Community 2022: Lessons from State Actions

Bold on Early Educator Compensation Learning Community 2022: Lessons from State Actions

(2026)

Over the past two years, pandemic funds like the American Rescue Plan Act (ARP) served as much-needed relief for our early care and education (ECE) system, a system in the midst of collapse. ARP dollars provided an opportunity to think differently about how we resource the early care and education workforce—those who work with children prior to kindergarten. However, emergency funding is insufficient to comprehensively address the long-standing low pay and lack of benefits facing early childhood educators. As the deadline for spending ARP funds approaches, what can we learn from state efforts to improve ECE compensation so that we see permanent change? Even as we acknowledge how racism, sexism, and classism have shaped the current ECE system, including our inadequate subsidy system, how do we ensure that policymakers design and implement compensation solutions equitably?

The Center for the Study of Child Care Employment (CSCCE) at UC Berkeley convened 20+ advocates and policymakers from seven states for the Bold on Early Educator Compensation Learning Community to dive into these questions in 2022.

Together, we shared challenges and strategies for progress on compensation for early educators. Insights from guest speakers advancing compensation progress in other places, such as Washington, D.C., supported our collective understanding. In this brief, we will review the key themes and lessons that emerged: act now and lay groundwork for compensation reform, dedicate funds, center educator voices, build data and evaluation capacity, and take a holistic approach.

Cover page of Pennsylvania Early Childhood Higher Education Inventory

Pennsylvania Early Childhood Higher Education Inventory

(2026)

This report describes the early childhood degree programs offered in Pennsylvania, focusing on variations in program content, age-group focus, student field-based learning, and faculty characteristics, as well as how Pennsylvania ECE higher education programs responded and adapted to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Cover page of Teaching Transitional Kindergarten: A Snapshot of the Teacher Experience Before UTK Expansion

Teaching Transitional Kindergarten: A Snapshot of the Teacher Experience Before UTK Expansion

(2026)

California is expanding transitional kindergarten (TK) to become a universal preschool program for all four-year-old children. Upwards of 300,000 children are expected to enroll in universal transitional kindergarten (UTK) by 2025, requiring thousands of additional lead teachers and classroom aides to meet lower student-to-teacher ratio requirements and new student demand (Melnick et al., 2022; Williams et al., 2021). While previous studies have documented the positive impact of TK on children’s learning (Banks et al., 2022; Manship et al., 2017; Sulik et al., 2023), this report presents the first comprehensive data collected from California’s transitional kindergarten teachers about their teaching experiences. 

Understanding what TK teachers themselves are saying about their preparation, work environments, and experiences is essential to ensuring a quality program as school, district, and state leaders plan for UTK expansion. In the fall of 2020, the Center for the Study of Child Care Employment (CSCCE) surveyed almost 300 TK teachers in classrooms throughout California as part of the California Early Care and Education Workforce Study. This report provides an exploratory picture of the composition of the TK workforce, the characteristics of the TK job, and the experience of teaching TK.

Cover page of The Kindergarten Lessons We Never Learned

The Kindergarten Lessons We Never Learned

(2026)

Today, free public kindergarten for five-year-old children is available in every state and community throughout the United States, and public education is routinely referred to as K-12. But kindergarten did not start out this way. Kindergartens in the United States once served children as young as three and four years old. In fact, today’s movement for public pre-kindergarten (pre-K) is a consequence of the gradual exclusion of almost all three- and four-year-olds from public kindergarten.

A century ago, the U.S. kindergarten landscape looked similar to preschool today. Kindergarten had limited public funding and was predominantly composed of private programs paid for by families and charitable donations. It took more than a hundred years to establish kindergarten as a public good.

Today, every five-year-old can go to a half-day of kindergarten for free in every community in the country.

In the mid-1800s, when it was new, kindergarten was a radical educational reform. Kindergarten was about children learning through play; it was about story time, building with blocks, and children drawing, singing, and playing together. Today, kindergarten is associated with homework, worksheets, and learning to read. Yet, in contrast to first- through twelfth-grade students, the children in kindergarten remain second-class citizens in the public education system. In most states, attendance is not mandatory and the kindergarten school day is shorter (Education Commission of the States, 2020b, 2020c). To make matters worse, kindergarten teachers are frequently paid less per hour than educators teaching older children (Kilander et al., 2022; McLean et al., 2021).

Cover page of CHIPS Child Care Requirement -- How Equitable Implementation Can Promote Stable, Well-Compensated Early Childhood Jobs

CHIPS Child Care Requirement -- How Equitable Implementation Can Promote Stable, Well-Compensated Early Childhood Jobs

(2026)

This policy brief provides guidance for advocates on how to influence implementation of the CHIPS Act child care requirement. By promoting quality jobs for the early childhood workforce and supporting small independent programs (especially those owned and/or operated by women of color), employer-sponsored child care will contribute to a system of stable, community-centered programs that address the diverse needs of their employees.

Cover page of Parent Preferences in Family, Friend, Neighbor, and Nanny Care

Parent Preferences in Family, Friend, Neighbor, and Nanny Care

(2026)

This is the first in a series of reports on the 2022 California Family, Friend, Neighbor (FFN), and Nanny Study. In this report, we discuss findings from a survey of California parents with children under age six. This report highlights parental care choices—both current and ideal—and the value that family, friend, neighbor (FFN), and nanny care holds for California parents.

Cover page of Early Educator Compensation

Early Educator Compensation

(2026)

Drawing on findings from the 2020 California Early Care and Education Workforce Study, this report provides statewide and regional wage and benefits data for home- and center- based early educators. Data are examined by education, program setting, and program funding. Despite a growing understanding of the importance of early learning and development and the expansion of quality improvement initiatives over the past 15 years, the wages we describe in this report reflect how little has been done to address the economic well-being of educators themselves.