Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Santa Barbara

UC Santa Barbara Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Santa Barbara

Ovarian Hormones and Their Impacts on Spatial Learning and Navigation

Abstract

Although women account for over half of the world’s population, there has been little work devoted to studying women’s health and cognition, especially from an endocrine perspective. This is particularly striking when changes in ovarian hormones (such as during menopause) are assumed to play a role in the risk of developing severe cognitive impairments, such as Alzheimer’s Disease. Navigation ability is one of the first cognitive abilities to deteriorate in early Alzheimer’s, women account for 2/3rds of all late-onset cases, and the risk for developing Alzheimer’s significantly increases after menopause. As such, it is important to understand how ovarian hormones are associated with the ability to navigate, as this can be a crucial marker for detecting early, more preventable stages of Alzheimer’s.Animal research has previously demonstrated positive effects of estradiol on navigation, especially on the ability to take novel, more efficient shortcuts (i.e., a place-based strategy) compared to previously learned, less efficient routes when wayfinding (i.e., a response-based strategy). However, little work has examined these effects in humans, and the work that has been conducted on ovarian hormones and spatial abilities has been primarily dedicated to small-scale spatial abilities, such as the ability to mentally rotate objects, rather than large-scale navigation ability. This dissertation investigates how hormones are associated with navigation ability and strategy in young adult women after learning the layout of a novel environment.Chapter I serves as an introduction to the dissertation, reviewing the literature on the history of spatial cognition research, sex differences in navigation, the brain and navigation, and what we know about ovarian hormones and navigation ability (from human and rodent studies). Chapter II develops the navigation task used in this research, which involves learning the layout of a novel environment and first examines the way in which we measure spatial learning in immersive and desktop virtual reality (VR) environments. In this chapter, Study 1 takes a within-subjects approach to examine if spatial learning is similar in desktop and immersive maze environments that are identical in relative structure and learning experience. Study 2, conducted between-subjects, examines spatial knowledge acquisition in identical maze environments that vary by interface (immersive ambulatory or desktop VR) and/or scale (10 x 10m or 55 x 55m).Across these studies, we found that while performance (via pointing and wayfinding efficiency) was significantly correlated across immersive and desktop interfaces, pointing performance (a measure of survey knowledge) was better in immersive VR than desktop possibly due to the inclusion of body-based cues from locomotion. However, wayfinding efficiency did not significantly differ between interfaces. We also found that the environment size did not impact spatial learning. These results collectively provide a bridge between Chapters III and IV, as these differed in the interface used to administer the tasks (immersive in Chapter III, desktop in Chapter IV).Chapter III examines effects of estradiol on navigation across the menstrual cycle, assessing navigation ability and strategy in young, naturally-cycling women in high estradiol (ovulatory window) and low estradiol (early follicular/menses) phases. This study takes a within-subjects approach, using immersive virtual reality environments to measure wayfinding efficiency, navigation strategy and onsite pointing ability, as well as a small-scale mental rotation task and general cognitive ability. Results indicate that women in the ovulatory window (when estradiol is high) had better pointing ability than when they were in the early follicular/menses phase (when estradiol is low), but contrary to previous hypotheses, there were no significant differences between cycle phase in wayfinding efficiency or navigation strategy. We additionally did not find any differences in mental rotation or general cognitive ability (e.g., processing speed, executive function, working memory, episodic memory, inhibition) across cycle phases.Chapter IV investigates chemically-induced ovarian hormone suppression on navigation ability in young adult women. A cohort of young, premenopausal women had ovarian hormones chemically suppressed for at least 3 months as a treatment for endometriosis (Cases). Age-matched young women, who did not undergo ovarian hormone suppression, were included to serve as a control group. Women were tested on navigation ability and strategy use in a desktop maze both before treatment (BL), and 3 months following onset of treatment (T3). We also measured a face-name associative memory task, as an additional measure of hippocampal function. In contrast to hypotheses, both groups significantly improved in performance over time in both wayfinding efficiency and place-based strategy use, and in the case of efficiency, Cases had relatively greater improvement over time (possibly due to minimized chronic pain or greater room for improvement). However, poorer pre-test (BL) performance for women with endometriosis (relative to their control counterparts) may be in part explained by impacts of chronic pain prior to treatment.Finally, Chapter V addresses the contribution of the studies in this dissertation, including the distinction between graph and survey knowledge acquisition in different interfaces and how spatial learning and navigation are influenced by changes in ovarian hormones, both at shorter- and longer-term timescales.