- Main
What Makes Policy Fair? Evidence from U.S. Immigrant Integration Policy and Public Opinion
- Trummel, Taylor
- Advisor(s): Bruhn, Kathleen;
- Nall, Clayton
Abstract
This dissertation asks how policy components influence perceptions of fairness and identifies the policy bundles that Americans are more likely to support. The research develops and validates a unique multidimensional measurement of fairness, advancing the study of public opinion methodologically and pushes the understanding of immigration attitudes beyond conventional debates. Chapter 1 outlines the theory and measurement approach and Chapter 2 uses an experimental design to identify the policy bundles Americans consider fair and support. Using an additional conjoint experiment, Chapter 3 tests whether the findings hold when explicit economic costs are included in the design. Using two original and nationally representative samples of more than 5,500 U.S. respondents from April 2025 and April 2026, I utilize pre-registered experiments to test how state-level immigrant integration policy features affect perceptions of fairness and policy support. I find that state policies that offer social services to immigrants and include eligibility criteria increase perceptions of fairness and policy support. Although Americans are found to be supportive of providing social services to immigrants, the results also emphasize the importance of eligibility criteria. Regardless of the region of origin among the immigrant group most likely to benefit from a hypothetical policy, immigrant utilization of services is considered fair, broadly defined, when these policies require a background check and legal immigration status. I also show that support for immigrant integration policy declines sharply as taxpayer costs increase. However, including eligibility requirements such as a criminal background check and proof of legal status substantially offset this opposition, commanding the highest willingness to pay among respondents. The results also show similar effects between partisans, suggesting an area of policy consensus among Americans for one of the most contentious issues of our time. Subnational governments seeking to build public support for integration services should therefore consider pairing such programs with clear eligibility criteria, particularly when funding depends on increasing taxes.