- Main
Wildfire Response Decision Making, Risk, and Interactions with Fuels Management in California
- Johnson, Andrew Swan
- Advisor(s): Stephens, Scott L;
- Collins, Brandon M
Abstract
Decisions made during and in preparation for wildland fires are dictated by many factors including the existing fuel profiles that determine fire behavior and fire perimeter access, both of which influence the decision space available to practitioners, safety concerns, and the ability to control fire spread. The following four chapters provide insight into how preventative management of wildland fuels impact operational decision making and quantified risk across large areas. First, I examine linear fuel breaks, a common fuel treatment type designed to be used by firefighters. Linear fuel breaks are constructed for landscape fire management and to protect highly valued resources when staffed by firefighters. Despite common implementation, controversy exists due to negative externalities and lack of clearly demonstrated effectiveness. Using input from practitioners, I determine how fuel breaks are planned, used, and how the outcomes they provide shape future implementation. I distributed a questionnaire to fire and fuels managers in California to determine end-user considerations during planning, construction, and fire response to provide detail to their diverse fire management applications. I created a descriptive decision-making framework for managers using fuel breaks that includes themes related to planning, construction, uses, outcomes, mediating factors, and general attitudes towards fuel breaks. Evaluations are determined by managers’ attitudes towards fuel breaks, which is influenced by previous experiences and landscape considerations, influencing future treatment design. During planning, environmental factors and preferred uses are incorporated into construction. While using fuel breaks, managers leverage altered fire behavior to increase first responder safety and the number of plausibly initiated tactics due to the reduced risk profile, varied temporal considerations, and altered fire trajectories. Based on our findings, I propose alternative methods of measuring fuel break efficacy and discuss the placement of linear treatments in broader land management strategies. Second, I quantify the risk reductions provided by fuel breaks. This study presents a framework to assess how fuel break configuration, arrangement, and firefighter tactics influence control opportunities using a new spatial metric for Uncontrollable Wildfire Risk (UWR). UWR combines outputs from fire modeling software widely available to fire and land management practitioners with suppression difficulty weights derived from previous literature. Fire spread simulations were conducted across four case study fuel break configurations in Southern California: Single Segment, Branching Network, Enclosed Network, and Multiple Segment Network. Three leverage scenarios representing different levels of suppression intervention (unstaffed, firebreak, and firing operations) were applied to each landscape. Linear mixed effects models and spatial analysis quantified the effects of distance from treatment, wind alignment, topography, treatment width, length, sinuosity, and proximity to other treatments on UWR. Results showed that increased leverage intensity consistently reduced UWR, while treatment geometry and spatial arrangement influenced risk reduction in some models. Notably, in some instances unstaffed fuel breaks increased burned area due to changes in fuel characteristics and subsequent fire behavior. This research highlights the importance of selecting appropriate outcomes for wildfire modeling evaluations of fuel break placement and operational utilization. Third, I investigate the tactical decision factors, processes, and outcomes on the 2021 Caldor Fire. The Caldor Fire destroyed 1,003 structures while costing $1.2 billion USD for suppression and recovery. Although these losses were substantial, statements from state and federal firefighting agencies indicate the worst potential impacts were avoided because of effective pre-fire fuels management and incident response. I interviewed fireline supervisors to investigate incident response decisions and the use of fuel treatments on the Caldor Fire. I conducted event-centered interviews using an ArcGIS Online map application as a visual-elicitation tool to determine: 1) What were the tactical decision-making processes and their contributing factors, and 2) how fuel treatments were incorporated into decisions. Based on interviews, I outlined a framework for tactical decision-making beginning with five criteria: operational, environmental, resource, risk, and institutional factors. Factors fed into three decision processes: sequencing actions, reactive or anticipatory, which were in pursuit of three primary objectives: protection of property and life, perimeter control, and holding pre-established containment line. Treatment characteristics and local knowledge determined whether fuel treatments were incorporated into tactical decisions. When incorporated, treatments increased containment effectiveness, resource efficiency, and firefighter safety. This work adds to the body of knowledge on incident decision making, indicating how time pressure, uncertainty, and pre-fire mitigation influence the planning and sequencing of tactical actions. Fourth, I explore how the decisions outlined in chapter 3 changed over time on the 2021 Caldor Fire. Operations on the Caldor Fire were complicated by extreme fire behavior and threats toward valuable resources. Outcomes varied over time, reflecting the influence of incident management. To examine how decisions on the Caldor Fire changed over time I describe the sequence of fire management operations in detail, eliciting detailed information on changing decisions and outcomes. I segmented the fire into four Operational Phases using fire progression and official documentation. I then conducted event-centered interviews using an ArcGIS Online map application as a visual-elicitation tool to determine how decisions changed over time. Changing decisions over time demonstrated how incident management decreased uncertainty for tactical decision makers. Reactive decisions dominated during early phases of the fire when there were notable impacts on the community of Grizzly Flats when the incident was being managed locally, and the fire grew rapidly. When extreme fire behavior occurred over a week later, after an Incident Management Team had been in place for a week, interviewees generally continued to make anticipatory decisions. The analysis of decision making over time demonstrates how fire governance can improve large fire management outcomes and where more structured decision making could improve future outcomes.