Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UCLA Criminal Justice Law Review

UCLA Criminal Justice Law Review bannerUCLA

Broken Data, Broken Justice: Systemic Inequities, a Data-Driven Approach

Abstract

This article critically examines the efficacy of recent California criminal justice reforms—most notably the Racial Justice Act, Blind Charging, Assembly Bill 2418, and Assembly Bill 1331—in addressing racial disparities within prosecutorial practices. Using Yolo County as a case study, the research employs a mixed-methods approach, combining quantitative analysis of prosecutorial data from the Measures for Justice Commons portal with legal and policy review, California Public Records Act requests, and a statewide survey of public defender offices. Findings reveal persistent racial disparities, particularly the disproportionate prosecution of Black residents, who are overrepresented at both the intake and prosecution stages despite the county’s adoption of race-blind charging policies. It identifies the deficiencies in data infrastructure—such as incomplete demographic disaggregation, absence of long-term diversion outcomes, and broad categorical groupings—that limit the capacity to measure reform impact and ensure accountability. These shortcomings underscore the inadequacy of reforms absent robust data transparency, standardized reporting, and independent oversight. The article advances recommendations for legislative and policy reform, including equity-focused data normalization, post-blind auditing of prosecutorial discretion, and establishment of independent oversight boards. By exposing how data gaps undermine well-intentioned reforms, this study argues that genuine justice requires more than statutory change; it demands equity-centered, transparent, and verifiable systems capable of translating legislative aspiration into measurable fairness.