Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UCLA Criminal Justice Law Review

UCLA Criminal Justice Law Review bannerUCLA

Restorative Justice in Schools: Ending the Criminalization of Trauma, Race, and 'Childlike' Behavior in Children

Abstract

Student misbehavior is a problem that education professionals have struggled to manage since public schools first emerged during the American colonial period. Traditionally, schools have employed harsh disciplinary approaches such as corporal punishment and zero-tolerance policies to manage adverse behavior. This paper interrogates the potential benefits of restorative justice practices in public schools, especially given the pervasive use of discipline and policing to target especially vulnerable students for misbehavior. How, if at all, can restorative justice address racial disparities in education that are both (1) rooted in generational and cultural trauma, poverty, and other social issues; and (2) reinforced by the carceral, discipline focused structures of the public school education system? The Article also outlines tactics and critiques surrounding the implementation of restorative justice in schools, as well as potential opportunities to yield more success moving forward. This inquiry concludes with a case study and critique centered upon the implementation of restorative practices at Los Angeles Unified School District. This Article seeks to expand upon legal scholarship on restorative justice in schools through an interdisciplinary approach discussing both the internal and external social forces associated with misconduct and punitive discipline which disproportionately affects students of color.