- Main
The Color of Innocence: Quantifying the Impact of Race on Wrongful Convictions
Published Web Location
https://doi.org/10.5070/CJ8.70318Abstract
The study of wrongful convictions in the United States is almost one hundred years old, and our understanding of the reasons for wrongful convictions remains rooted in longstanding framing of the issue. Using observational research of documented wrongful convictions, scholars have recognized several factors that have been present in the cases of those whose wrongful convictions have been documented. Racism has been long understood to contribute to wrongful convictions, but it is not included in the standard list of leading contributing factors. Given this omission, attempts to examine increasingly rich data sets often provide a very surface-level analysis of the role of race in producing wrongful convictions.
This article reviews the intersection of racism with the traditional list of contributing factors. There is considerable overlap between racism and each factor, but racism has an independent impact on the cases of exonerees, the majority of whom are Black. As such, racism merits independent examination as a contributing factor in and of itself.
The feasibility of this contributing factor is tested on a subset of existing publicly available exoneration data by focusing on a particularly relevant subset of exonerations, those in which the exonerated individual was originally sentenced to death. The test is carried out by defining potential confines for a racism contributing factor and evaluating the past twenty years of death penalty exonerations using this definition. Though imperfect, the test shows that a racism contributing factor would apply to a significant percentage of cases of defendants of color.
This article demonstrates the possibilities for independently quantifying the role of racism in wrongful convictions. Such assessment could provide a foundation for a more nuanced understanding of race effects in this specialized area of empirical scholarship. Empirical research has been central to pursuing remedies for wrongful convictions and procedural reforms to prevent them from occurring in the first place. Without a full understanding of the role of race in these cases, the story being told by the data and any proposed solutions flowing from this analysis are missing a crucial component.