Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California
Cover page of Scaling Equity: Unfulfilled Promises and Lessons From California’s MTSS Initiative

Scaling Equity: Unfulfilled Promises and Lessons From California’s MTSS Initiative

(2025)

In this report, we present findings from the qualitative data collection and analysis of publicly available data of the California Multi-Tiered System of Support (CA MTSS) Pilot Phase II. This report aims to describe, through administrator interviews conducted by the UCLA Center for the Transformation of Schools (CTS) research team, the factors that influenced the implementation of the CA MTSS Pilot Phase II during the fourth year of participation in Phase 2A and the second year of participation in Phase 2B. The CA MTSS Pilot Phase II encompasses 35 schools from 26 districts across California as they implement the MTSS framework at the school level, focusing on school climate, positive behavioral supports, and social-emotional learning. Additionally, this report shares longitudinal findings from the qualitative data collection and analysis of the California Scaling Up Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS) Statewide (SUMS)for Phases 2A and 2B during the 2018–19 through 2022–23 school years. It presents findings based on publicly available data and approximately 60 administrator interviews conducted by the CTS research team during the CA MTSS Pilot Phase II. This pilot is part of an effort to expand “the state’s Multi-Tiered System of Support framework to foster a positive school climate in both academic and behavioral areas” (California Assembly Bill 1808, 2018).Learn more on the CTS website.

  • 1 supplemental PDF
Cover page of The Ten Billion Dollar Deficit: The Economic Burdens of Inequities Across California Schools

The Ten Billion Dollar Deficit: The Economic Burdens of Inequities Across California Schools

(2025)

Study’s Purpose:

California’s public schools face significant pressure to improve across a range of metrics, to improve educational efficiency and reduce inequities between student groups. One student support framework is the Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS), which includes screening of students’ needs, monitoring their progress, data-based decision making and a multi-level prevention system. MTSS has the potential to maximize student success. However, to set MTSS in context, it is necessary to calculate the full economic consequences of failing to invest in MTSS (and other educational support strategies).

Here we investigate the economic consequences of failure to graduate from high school; chronic absenteeism; and disciplinary sanctions (suspension, expulsion, and restraint). Applying a standard economic model, we calculate the burdens to society, families, schools, and the California taxpayer. We find significant burdens from each perspective and that these burdens vary by race and student disadvantage. For example, there are racial inequities in how many students get suspended as well as the economic burden of these suspensions.

Research Methods:

We model the economic burdens across these three challenges—high school failure, absenteeism, and disciplinary actions—using a life-course trajectory model (Boardman et al., 2018; Levin et al., 2018) to estimate the long-term financial burdens of high school failure, absenteeism, and disciplinary actions in California. By assigning shadow prices—reflecting society’s willingness to pay for improvements—the model calculates lifetime costs and fiscal impacts from the perspectives of students, families, schools, and taxpayers. These costs are monetized using 2023 dollars and discounted to present value. The analysis reveals significant societal and fiscal gains from high school graduation, and substantial burdens from absenteeism and disciplinary sanctions, especially due to their effects on educational attainment and long-term earnings.

Key Findings:

Summary results show a social gain of almost one-half million dollars per extra high school graduate. For a 3 percentage point increase in the state-wide high school graduation rate, California would gain almost $10 billion in total and $3 billion in taxpayer savings. Economic calculations (Table S2) show the substantial economic burden for students who are off-track or have been disciplined. For each student who is chronically absent, the burden is $5,630. Disciplinary social burdens are also high: for each expulsion, for example, the social burden is $70,870.

Conclusion:

These calculations provide compelling evidence that educational support strategies such as MTSS are needed and that there is significant potential for them to be socially efficient.

Cover page of The MONARCH Room® Model: Implementation Findings From Trauma Sensory Processing Rooms in Schools

The MONARCH Room® Model: Implementation Findings From Trauma Sensory Processing Rooms in Schools

(2024)

This study examined the implementation of the MONARCH Room®—a trauma-informed sensory space designed as an alternative to punitive discipline—in 12 middle and high schools within the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD). Aimed at supporting students with trauma histories, particularly foster-involved youth who are disproportionately subject to suspension and expulsion, the initiative was implemented in partnership with Comprehensive Coordinated Early Intervening Services (CCEIS). School staff (“Champions,” n=116) completed baseline surveys assessing trauma-informed knowledge and school climate, participated in training modules, and engaged in two rounds of focus groups (n=62) between September 2023 and February 2024. Findings indicated strong staff support for trauma-informed approaches but identified key implementation barriers, including limited training opportunities, challenges securing dedicated space, competing responsibilities, mixed teacher perceptions, and funding constraints. Despite these challenges, schools reported promising outcomes: improved student emotional self-regulation, reductions in some disciplinary referrals, and a gradual shift among staff from punitive to supportive practices. Increased collaboration and growing buy-in were also noted over time. Overall, the MONARCH Room® demonstrates potential as an effective intervention for fostering supportive school environments, though addressing systemic barriers will be essential for long-term sustainability and impact.

Cover page of Leveraging CA MTSS to Support English Learner-Classified Students: Insights from Three CA Districts

Leveraging CA MTSS to Support English Learner-Classified Students: Insights from Three CA Districts

(2023)

This brief highlights findings from a study focused on how California’s Multi-Tiered System of Support (CA MTSS) framework serves English- Learner (EL) classified students. Our findings are based on analyses of interview data with district- and school site-based educators from three districts in California that are relatively successful in serving their EL-classified student populations and are diverse in their geographical locations, size, and linguistic demographics. Key findings include: Existing EL-related services were difficult to incorporate into the framework of tiered supports; Advocacy for EL-classified students was important within MTSS planning processes to encourage shared responsibility for these students; Engaging parents, families, and caregivers of EL-classified students in meaningful relationships was easier at the Tier 2 level; and EL-classified student density within a district or school affected how MTSS structures were organized. This brief is part of The Landscape of Language Learners in California’s MTSS (Multi-Tiered System of Support) series. Learn more on the CTS website.

Cover page of Lessons from the Pilot of MTSS School Site-Implementation

Lessons from the Pilot of MTSS School Site-Implementation

(2023)

This policy brief distills key lessons on policy implementation, content, and rollout from the pilot phase of the Scaling Up MTSS Statewide Initiative that supported school-site implementation of the Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS). This brief details how educators’ experiences with other tiered intervention programs fundamentally shaped how MTSS implementation unfolded at school sites. This was due in large part to the MTSS framework being too broad in scope to provide schools with clarity and guidance; too narrow in how student behaviors are assessed and addressed to facilitate innovation; and silent on issues of race and culture. Troublingly, the rollout of the pilot in terms of funding model, site selection processes, and support structures likely aggravated existing resource inequalities between schools. Recommendations for future MTSS-related initiatives build on these insights. Learn more on the CTS website.

Cover page of The State of Academic Performance

The State of Academic Performance

(2023)

This brief depicts trends related to academic performance, namely trends in English-Learner (EL) classified student performance on Math and English Language Arts (ELA) SBAC (Smarter Balanced Assessment System) assessments. CA MTSS is a comprehensive framework that aligns academic, behavioral, social and emotional learning and mental health supports in a fully integrated system of support to benefit all students. By providing a comprehensive and individualized approach to academic support, MTSS can help EL-classified students overcome academic challenges and achieve academic success. Key findings include: A small percentage of EL students are meeting or exceeding standards: 9.2% in mathematics and 12.5% in English Language Arts, suggesting that the education system may not adequately support the progression and achievement of English Learners, particularly as they advance to higher grade levels; EL students are performing better academically in elementary compared to secondary grades; and The more proficient a student is in English Language, the more proficient they are in Math and English Language Arts. This brief is part of the Landscape of Language Learners in California’s MTSS (Multi-Tiered System of Support). Learn more on the CTS website.

Cover page of The State of High School Graduation Rates

The State of High School Graduation Rates

(2023)

This report examines disparities in high school graduation outcomes between English-Learner classified students (ELs) and non-English-Learner classified students in California within the context of the state’s Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS) framework. Using statewide graduation and college-readiness data from 2018–2022, including Four-Year Adjusted Cohort Graduation Rates and district-level comparisons across California’s largest school districts, the study analyzes trends in graduation rates and eligibility for University of California and California State University admission. Findings indicate that although overall graduation rates in California improved from 83.0% in 2018 to 87.0% in 2022, EL graduation rates remained consistently lower, increasing only from 67.9% to 71.8% during the same period. Significant disparities also persisted in college readiness, with EL students demonstrating substantially lower rates of meeting UC/CSU admission requirements compared to the general student population. The report concludes that persistent inequities in academic achievement and graduation outcomes necessitate targeted, evidence-based interventions through MTSS, including comprehensive language development, tiered academic supports, culturally responsive practices, and coordinated collaboration among educators, families, and communities to improve educational equity and long-term outcomes for English-Learner classified students in California.

Cover page of The State of Reclassification

The State of Reclassification

(2023)

This report examines trends in the reclassification of English-Learner classified students (ELs) within California’s Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS) framework, with the purpose of identifying patterns in enrollment, language proficiency, and long-term English learner status to inform educational policy and practice. Using statewide California Department of Education data from 2017–2022, the study analyzes changes in EL enrollment, Reclassified Fluent English Proficient (RFEP) rates, Long-Term English Learner (LTEL) populations, and district-level reclassification trends across the ten largest school districts in California. Findings indicate a substantial decline in overall EL enrollment, from 1.33 million students in 2017 to 1.06 million in 2021, alongside fluctuating reclassification rates that peaked at 14.6% in 2018 before dropping to 6.9% in 2021, likely due to disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. The study also found growing LTEL populations in several districts and significant variation in RFEP rates across districts. The report concludes that targeted interventions, comprehensive language support, collaborative instructional practices, and data-informed MTSS implementation are essential to improving reclassification outcomes and promoting equitable educational opportunities for EL students in California.

Cover page of Through MTSS, Empathic Discipline Program Can Mitigate Racial Disparities in Suspension Rates

Through MTSS, Empathic Discipline Program Can Mitigate Racial Disparities in Suspension Rates

(2023)

Research and practice highlight the need for fewer student behavior problems in schools and the need for more equitable disciplinary outcomes.

The empathic discipline program is an intervention for teachers that is designed to mitigate the consequences of bias on their students’ education outcomes, namely exclusionary discipline. The present research tested whether the empathic discipline program could be implemented through MTSS (Multi-Tiered System of Support) networks in a large and diverse school district and whether it could mitigate yearlong suspension rates. As compared to control conditions, the empathic discipline program meaningfully reduced yearlong suspension rates and mitigated racial disparities in them. Implications and recommendations are discussed.Learn more on the CTS website.

Cover page of The Economic Benefits of Equity Across California Schools

The Economic Benefits of Equity Across California Schools

(2023)

California’s students face a number of challenges that have been greatly exacerbated by the pandemic. Low public funding state-wide, compounded over many years, has meant slow growth in learning and educational productivity. Disadvantaged and minority students lag far behind such that there are large inequities across California’s K-12 system. There is a compelling need for reform and for additional investment to address these challenges and to reduce systemic inequities. This brief summarizes our economic analysis of three specific –and related – issues facing California’s public school system: students’ failure to complete high school, chronic absenteeism, and disciplinary infractions. We identify substantial benefits if there are improvements across any of these domains. Improvements might be general – affecting all students — or they might be targeted – reducing gaps by race or level of disadvantage. Learn more on the CTS website.