The oxidation of substrates via the cleavage of thermodynamically strong C-H bonds is an essential part of mammalian metabolism. These reactions are predominantly carried out by enzymes that produce high-valent metal-oxido species, which are directly responsible for cleaving the C-H bonds. While much is known about the identity of these transient intermediates, the mechanistic factors that enable metal-oxido species to accomplish such difficult reactions are still incomplete. For synthetic metal-oxido species, C-H bond cleavage is often mechanistically described as synchronous, proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). However, data have emerged that suggest that the basicity of the M-oxido unit is the key determinant in achieving enzymatic function, thus requiring alternative mechanisms whereby proton transfer (PT) has a more dominant role than electron transfer (ET). To bridge this knowledge gap, the reactivity of a monomeric MnIV-oxido complex with a series of external substrates was studied, resulting in a spread of over 104 in their second-order rate constants that tracked with the acidity of the C-H bonds. Mechanisms that included either synchronous PCET or rate-limiting PT, followed by ET, did not explain our results, which led to a proposed PCET mechanism with asynchronous transition states that are dominated by PT. To support this premise, we report a semiempirical free energy analysis that can predict the relative contributions of PT and ET for a given set of substrates. These findings underscore why the basicity of M-oxido units needs to be considered in C-H functionalization.