- Main
Modernist Taste
- Taylor, Bradford Alden
- Advisor(s): Blanton, C.D.
Abstract
Modernist Taste offers a philosophical account of taste in early-twentieth-century Anglo-American modernism. Against readings that treat taste as either a catalog of cultural preferences or a vehicle for subjective mnemonic recovery, this dissertation argues that a small group of modernist authors—Ford Madox Ford, Wyndham Lewis, and Rebecca West—subject taste to a rigorous reformulation, transforming it from an inherited faculty of disinterested aesthetic judgment into a dialectically unstable mode of historical registration. Drawing on Kant’s Critique of the Power of Judgment, Hegel’s aesthetics, Marx’s materialist account of the senses, Simmel, Freud, Adorno, and Gadamer, this project seeks to construct the formal logic of modernist taste. This dissertation is organized into three sections. GOOD TASTE reads Ford Madox Ford as the elegist of traditional aesthetic taste, whose melancholic attachment to the codes of a receding public sphere yields, in The Good Soldier and his critical writings, a reconceptualization of taste as what this project calls the “historic sense”: a materialist attunement to the persistence of contradiction that vision can register only as error. The section concludes with a reading of Cézanne’s still life and landscape paintings through the discourse of Roger Fry and Clive Bell, arguing that impressionism’s most rigorous achievement is the registration of material resistance to the will to pure form. BAD TASTE turns to Wyndham Lewis’s early fiction and criticism, where taste is activated as an aggressive, digestive aesthetic force. Lewis negates the “dilettante” form of taste while refashioning it into a faculty of violent assimilation—an aesthetics of nastiness in which the object overtakes its own representation. AFTER TASTE reads Lewis’s Tarr and Rebecca West’s “Indissoluble Matrimony” against each other, arguing that West’s portrait of Evadne Silverton constitutes an immanent critique of Vorticism’s chauvinist aesthetics and relocates taste’s universality from Kantian transcendental subjectivity to the concrete, collective universality Hegel identifies with objective spirit. This transition inaugurates a movement beyond taste—toward an ontological account of aesthetic freedom that modernist form can register only as a foreclosed possibility. Throughout, Modernist Taste contends that the dominant visual aesthetics of modernism, with its drive toward purified perception and immediate presence, tends to occlude the historical conditions of its own emergence. Taste—marginalized and minor—retains a different sensitivity: it registers what vision, fixed on the surface, cannot detect.