Frontiers of Biogeography

As environmental conditions change over time, some species can follow the spatial footprint of their ecological niches or can adapt physiologically to the new conditions; modifying behavior can offer an alternative means of adapting to novel environments. The burrowing habit allows organisms to avoid adverse climatic conditions during part of the year by remaining inside burrows. Smilisca fodiens and S. dentata are two burrowing hylid frogs that inhabit areas beyond the northernmost distributional limits of the other six arboreal species of their genus, and indeed beyond of most American hylids. In this study, we tested whether burrowing habit allows these species to adapt to drier conditions while conserving the climatic niche of the arboreal species. We compared the annual niches of the arboreal species to those of the burrowing species under two assumptions: true seasonal niches and full annual niches. Through ecological niche similarity tests, we performed 24 comparisons in both geographic and environmental spaces. In geographic space, when considering burrowing annual niches, only five of 24 tests indicated similarity, yet as regards seasonal niche, 18 of 24 tests indicated similarity. In environmental space, all tests failed to reject null hypotheses. The analyses showed clearly that burrowing and arboreal species were closer in environmental space when seasonal niches of the burrowing species were used, rather than annual niches. That is, climatic conditions in seasonal niches of burrowing species resemble the annual niches of arboreal species, supporting the proposition that reduction of activity to certain periods of the year is a strategy in burrowing species to conserve their tropical niches while living in dry regions.