“Definition from Above”: Industrial Philanthropy and the Shaping of Racialized and Gendered Education for Black Students in the Early Twentieth Century
Skip to main content
eScholarship
Open Access Publications from the University of California

UC Berkeley

UC Berkeley Electronic Theses and Dissertations bannerUC Berkeley

“Definition from Above”: Industrial Philanthropy and the Shaping of Racialized and Gendered Education for Black Students in the Early Twentieth Century

Abstract

My dissertation uncovers the historical roots of the patriarchal gender norms and public-private partnerships that pervade education policy for Black youth in the United States today. I conducted an archival study of two Northern industrial philanthropies—the General Education Board (G.E.B.), funded by oil tycoon John D. Rockefeller, and the Rosenwald Fund, funded by Sears & Roebuck C.E.O. Julius Rosenwald—that centrally shaped Southern Black education in the early twentieth century. Both funds mandated that schools they supported have a vocational focus, training Black youth for labor roles following those that Black people had filled during slavery—agricultural or low-skilled industrial labor for boys and domestic service work for girls. While many scholars have studied the racialized elements of U.S. education philanthropy, few have taken an intersectional, gendered perspective. To help fill this gap, I conducted archival research at both these foundations’ archives, analyzing correspondence, meeting minutes, photographs, and reports to understand their funding structures and relationships with Black schools. I also consulted the Wilcox County School Board archive in Alabama to learn more about one school, Snow Hill Normal and Industrial Institute. Finally, I visited the site of the shuttered Snow Hill school and conducted oral history interviews with community members. My archival analysis is rooted in the epistemologies of intersectionality, Black feminist historiography, Black Studies, and racial capitalism, which contend that power pervades the historical record. I found that funding decisions were overwhelmingly rooted in Black schools’ willingness to adhere to gender-segregated vocational curricula. The G.E.B. also funded gender-segregated agricultural clubs called corn cobbing clubs for boys and canning clubs for girls. I argue that the G.E.B. and Rosenwald Fund intentionally rooted their education models in gender segregation and patriarchal norms as an essential strategy for ensuring their ideal economic conditions. This model became the lasting foundation for public education in the region. I also found that Black educators and communities resisted and subverted the foundations’ efforts to constrain their autonomy.